Page 36 of Margin of Error


Font Size:

“I am. Let’s do this.”

Slowly but surely, she was completing her to-do list. Puppy—check. House—check. Now she needed a woman to hold. Looking at Charlotte, she felt that all-too-familiar jolt in the pit of her stomach. But no matter how badly Marin wished otherwise, Charlotte wasn’t the one.

Chapter Ten

Charlotte stood in line at the deli counter at the Main Street Café, waiting to pick up sandwiches for her and Marin. It was Saturday, a full week since they’d looked at the house on Middleton Hill Road, and they were going to have lunch at Marin’s apartment before Charlotte headed out for an afternoon of house showings.

Marin’s offer on the house had been accepted almost immediately, with a closing set for the first weekend in March, which meant soon Charlotte would just be Marin’s friend, not her Realtor.

“Charlotte?”

She glanced behind her, and everything seemed to freeze as her gaze settled on the woman standing there. It had been a long time—over twenty years, in fact—since Charlotte had last seen her, but the recognition was immediate and overwhelming. “Elena.”

Elena Campos looked much the same as she had in high school, dark curls framing her face, light-brown skin that seemed sun kissed even in the middle of a Vermont winter. She was smiling at Charlotte, and ...thatwas unexpected. “I heard you were back in town, but well ... hi.”

“Hi.” Charlotte felt flushed and tongue tied, because how were you supposed to greet the woman who had been your best friendthrough high school, who you’d fallen out with just before graduation and hadn’t spoken to since? “I ... wow ... it’s really good to see you.”

“You too.” Elena was still smiling, but something hesitant had entered her eyes now, as if she was remembering the way they’d crashed and burned senior year, just like Charlotte was. “I’d love to catch up sometime.”

“So would I.” Charlotte’s body was on high alert, a confusing cocktail of emotions sweeping through her veins as she realized that deep down, she’d been afraid of this, that Elena still lived in town and Charlotte might bump into her. Shame followed, because this woman had been herbestfriend, and their friendship-ending fight seemed petty and insignificant now. “I’m on my way to meet someone, but maybe we could grab lunch sometime?”

“I’d love that. Can I get your number?” Elena held out her phone.

Charlotte glimpsed a photo of Elena with two teen girls who were unmistakably her daughters on the lock screen, and it hit her like a punch in the gut just how much time had passed since they’d spoken. How had she let that happen?

Charlotte tapped her number into Elena’s phone and said goodbye, but she was still reeling as she walked outside a few minutes later, holding a paper bag that contained her and Marin’s lunch. Elena’s family had moved to Vermont the summer before Charlotte and Elena started high school, and almost as soon as they’d met, they’d become inseparable.

Sometimes friendships were just like that, weren’t they? One day, you didn’t even know each other, and the next day you had connected on a soul-deep level. Charlotte had experienced it twice ... first with Elena, and then with Marin. She and Elena had spent practically every free moment at each other’s houses, talking about clothes and music and which boys they liked.

They’d both dated a lot, but senior year, they’d promised each other they would attend prom together. It was going to be their last hurrah before going off to college, and no boy would come betweenthem. But midway through senior year, Elena had gotten serious with her boyfriend, Marcus. He’d asked her to the prom, and she’d said yes.

Charlotte, who’d been single at the time, had been so upset, sohurt. They had a huge fight, and in the end, Charlotte lost her best friend. It had felt like such a big deal at the time, and now ... well, now it felt like she’d thrown away an important friendship over something trivial. But maybe she was about to get a chance to fix that mistake.

She got in her car and drove to Marin’s apartment. Marin greeted her at the door, looking exhausted and a bit disheveled, but she wasradiant. Having a puppy really agreed with her.

“Perfect timing.” Marin spoke quietly, then put a finger to her lips. “Ember just fell asleep, so if we’re quiet, we can eat lunch without puppy interference.”

“Challenge accepted,” Charlotte whispered.

“You okay?” Marin asked, giving her a questioning look. “You look kind of intense.”

“I just bumped into my best friend from high school, and it really threw me.” She spoke softly as they sat across from each other at the kitchen table. “We had a big falling-out senior year, and we haven’t spoken since.”

“That’s a long time,” Marin observed. “What did you fight about?”

“A guy.” Charlotte rolled her eyes. “It seems so stupid now, and I guess ... seeing her today made me realize that. Like, she has teenage daughters I’ve never met. I have no idea what’s going on in her life. And we wereinseparableall through high school.”

“It happens, and you moving out of state certainly didn’t help you two reconnect.”

“No. If I’d gone to NU like so many kids from our high school—including Elena—we probably would have made up in college. If I’m honest, our fight was part of the reason I left Vermont after high school. Everything here felt so overwhelming and messed up, and I just needed a fresh start. Anyway, we exchanged numberstoday, but I feel so weird about the whole thing. Our fight was my fault. At the time, I blamed her for choosing her boyfriend over me, but now I see that I was just being immature and stupid.”

“It’s what teenagers are best at, right?”

“I guess. I haven’t spent much time around teens since I was one.”

Marin chuckled. “I’ve spent enough time with nieces and nephews—and even great-nieces and nephews—to have experienced my fair share of teen drama.”

“That must seem so weird, your siblings being grandparents already,” Charlotte said. “I mean, I don’t feel nearly old enough for that.”