Before Colin and Daniel, exhibitionism wasn't my thing, but maybe the problem wasn't that I was turned off by it so much as I had never considered doing it with the right people.
“Yes,” I hissed. My eyes rolled back in my head and I licked my lips as I allowed myself to feel everywhere Colin’s hands roamed. My dick throbbed inside my pants, and I wanted to beg him to get me off. A little stress relief would make it much easier to people tonight.
“You’re so damn perfect when you stop overthinking things. It's going to be hard to keep my hands off you,” Colin admitted, giving my dick a couple quick strokes over my jeans. I bucked my hips, chasing his touch as he released me.
I nearly jumped when someone pounded on the door, but Colin held me tight. Daniel appeared in front of me, wrapping his arms tightly around both of us, the two of them caging me in so I couldn't run away.
If you assholes are riding with the rest of us, you better get your dicks put away and your asses in gear,” Jayden hollered.
My entire face flamed red-hot with embarrassment. It felt different from before when they knew I was screwing random women in my room. Now, they all knew the one secret I'd tried to hide from everyone: that a dick shoved up my ass turned me on quicker than sticking my cock in any hole could.
“Daniel and I will wait for you out in the living room,” Colin informed me. He picked up my sweater and tossed it to me. “If we’re all in here, we’ll never leave.”
“That sounds like a damn good idea to me.”
"Ha, you wish,” Daniel scoffed. “Maybe if you hurry, Colin will give you a treat when we get home.”
“Do I look like a fucking puppy to you?” I ground out.
Daniel scrubbed his chin and glanced at Colin. The two of them flashed mirroring smirks, and I knew I was in trouble.
“It was a figure of speech guys,” I quickly protested. The two of them were dangerous. God only knew what predicament I’d find myself in if they started conspiring against me.
“I don't know, I bet you’d look cute with a little tail sticking out of your ass. You’d love that—feeling the weight of the plug pressing on your prostate as it stretched you out. And we could find you a hood. You might like it.”
“No way.” No. I held my hands up in protest. “You guys are not turning me into your little human puppy.”
“Don't knock it until you try it,” Colin advised. “I think Daniel is right. That might be something we need to explore at some point.”
“No, we don’t,” I assured them. This was me putting my foot down. I’d read a bit about puppy play and, while it was intriguing, it wasn’t for me. “I thought the two of you were waiting for me out there.” I made a shooing motion, hoping they'd get the hell out and give me a couple minutes of privacy to get my aching dick under control.
“Have you even thought about it? Do you know what it's about?” Daniel teased. “It wasn’t that long ago, you swore you weren’t into guys, either. Is this like that?”
“Yeah. I've heard of it,” I told them. “And, no, this isn’t like me being scared to come out. I don't need to be paraded around on a leash.”
Jayden sounded at the door again. “Come on, fuckers. We’re wasting time.”
“Why the hell is he in such a hurry?” I grumbled as I pulled on my sweater.
It was weird how excited everyone else was about the fall festival. It wasn't a campus thing, where everyone there would be our age and the beer would be flowing freely. This was a family event at some farm on the other side of town.
“You seriously haven't figured it out yet?” Colin rolled his eyes. He held out a hand to me as I stuffed my feet into my boots. They were tight and stiff because I rarely wore them, but Colin had picked them out, so I would suffer through whatever pain they caused me. “Pay close attention tonight. I think you are about to learn even more about your roommates than they’ll figure out about us.”
“Or one of you two assholes could just tell me?” I protested. Maybe I should be happy the two of them were so respectful of other people’s privacy; it meant I didn’t have to worry about either of them over-sharing about us. But being on the outside sucked. I wanted them to tell me because that’s what partners did. We weren’t supposed to keep secrets from one another.
Colin’s palm cracked against my hip. “Watch your tone.”
The swat didn’t hurt, but I still rubbed the spot where he’d hit me. That had the opposite effect of what needed to happen. I was even harder now and could feel a damp spot in the front of my underwear. “I’m sorry.”
“I know you are.” Colin cradled my face and brushed his cheek against mine as he whispered, “It’s not that I don’t want to tell you, but this is something I really think will be easier if you pay attention and then ask questions.”
“Okay.” His soothing voice worked to extinguish my frustration and feelings of being left out. As it turned out, I didn’t need them to wait for me in the other room. I slipped my hand into Colin’s. I would have taken Daniel’s as well, but that would just look weird. “I’m ready to go.”
* * *
I foughtthe urge to roll my eyes as we got out of Brandon’s new SUV. We were seriously out of place here. Every other family in the parking lot had little kids in tow, and then there was a group of college kids. We’d probably get the side eye from everyone, even if they didn’t realize we were all gay.
“Relax, it’s going to be fun,” Colin promised me as he fell in step beside me. “Who knows, this might be just what all of us need to get rid of the last of the tension at home.”
