The look on his face when I came back with the lube and butt plugwas just too priceless.
Let's see how much he enjoys taking it up the ass, along with a good-sized helping of humiliation. I gave him my best smile, batting my lashes coyly. I enjoyed this game. Whatever I subject him to, he deserves.
"Now, mypet,you’re going to be a good boy and take this plug up your ass, and if you make one sound while I brutally fuck your bottom, you will be punished."
He scowled but spoke sincerely.
"Kitlyn, I know you are pissed at me, and I won't try to dissuade you from taking your revenge. Just show me the same mercy I showed you when I took your anal cherry. I don't want to end up bleeding out all over the floor from a tear or a perforation, so please, go easy on me, pe- uh, Kitlyn."
I grinned, feeling very vindictive.
"No worries, Atlas. I will show you the same courtesy you showed me. Now, knees to chest, big boy. I know you can lift those gorgeous, muscular legs. Now do as I asked, or I will get angry and dry fuck your ass."
Keep your head together, Atlas. Don't lose your shit. Look at it as another kinky game with the woman you can't get enough of.
Atlas
I lifted my knees to my chest. It wasn't a simple task because she had my ankles tethered together in these fucking cuffs. I watched her grab the lube and slather it all over the butt plug, then she quickly smeared it along my entrance. I've never been fucked in the ass, and I was sure this was going to be painful, especially if she didn't do it correctly. I'll take a dose of my own medicine.
Maybe Idodeserve this. I can own up to my mistakes, but if she doesn't do this properly, she could tear up my ass apart, and I could end up in someserious shit, no pun intended. I looked at her, still with no emotion on my face.
"Kitlyn, if you need some guidance, I will help you. Did I seriously hurt you when I took you anally? Just answer me truthfully, and I will keep quiet."
Kitlyn
I looked at him, not feeling all that victorious right now. He didn't hurt me, but this isn't about hurting him; it's about humiliating him like he humiliated me.
"This has nothing to do with pain, Atlas; it has to do with embarrassment. Debasing you, making you feel less than. I want you to feel what it's like to be a woman in a man's world." I applied the lube to his puckered hole, digging around the entrance for extra measure.
He tightened up, but he made no sound.
"Just for a few minutes, Atlas, let's pretend you are me, and I am you while I slowly fuck your helpless ass. I was as vulnerable as you are now, because you are much larger than I am. I had no strength to fight you off, and now you will know what that felt like for me."
I pulled my shiny finger away from his bottom, wiping it on his leg. My voice was dripping with sweetness.
"I want you to be a good pet and take it like a good boy. I will talk you through it, love. So just relax those muscles while I fuck that sweet ass."
Chapter 35
Atlas
I can't believe this little witch has me bound up and is going to defile my virgin asshole. I don't give a flying fuck about her little warning about me not following her or bringing her back here. The other tracker's in her neck, and you bet your ass I will watch her.
When I take her the next time, she will never be free again, and she will be punished and locked up like a caged animal. Although I probably deserve this, it is irrelevant. I am the only one who should be in charge. Not this little twirp.
I am skilled in anal, but she is not. If she uses that thing up my ass brutally, it could ruin me for life. I tried not to tense up, waiting for her to violate me.
I allowed my mind to wander, hoping this would be over quickly. She would be satisfied with her revenge, escape; then, I would hunt her down again. I waited for a good five minutes, but nothing happened. I turned to look at her.
She was sitting on the kitchen chair with tears in her eyes. I was so zoned out, waiting for the attack, that I didn't sense her moving away from me. The threat of being sodomized with a huge butt plug will make a person check out mentally.
I had to keep cool.
I didn't want to anger her any more than she already was.
" Kitlyn, why are you crying? Just take your revenge, and you can go. I won't follow you or threaten you again."
That was a fucking lie, but I would not tell her that while she held my life and the health of my ass in her hands.
