That seems to help because a moment later, she gasps my name and her pussy clamps down on me.
“Grayson! Oh my God,Grayson!”
Then she’s coming, and I let myself go. I grip her hips and thrust up into her rapidly. I assume the view from the front is hot, her tits bouncing, her thighs open, her pussy stretched wide.
“Caroline!” I shout as I erupt. I come hard, filling my woman with my seed and, for just a brief moment, I actually hope I do get her pregnant.
The thought passes quickly. There’s plenty of time for that and God knows we have our hands full with the babies we’ve got, but it is a primal instinct to claim Caroline this way the first time I actually fuck her and do it bare.
“Spread those gorgeous legs for me,” James says roughly. Caroline moves off me and lies back on the bed right next to me. She spreads her legs, her hand playing in her pussy and I prop up, not wanting to miss the filthy view of her spreading my cum over her pussy and clit.
“Jesus Christ," Cas says, shaking his head. “You’re a fucking dream.”
“How do you want me?” she asks.
“Naked all day, every day,” Cas tells her with a grin.
But I have a specific idea about this too. I scoot up the bed. “Come here, Caroline.”
She rolls to her stomach and crawls toward me. I cup her face and kiss her deeply, then move her so she’s reclining against me. I pull her legs apart, draping them over mine, spreading her wide for her other men.
“Fuck her hard," I tell James. “I guess I didn’t wear her out yet.”
A ghost of a smile—a very pleased, almost smug smile—crosses her lips.
I lean in and say against her ear. “You’re going to feel us all day tomorrow,” I promise.
“Big talker,” she teases.
But then James thrusts into her and she gasps.
I smirk at her and brush her hair back from her face. “You okay?”
Her eyes slide shut in pleasure. “So okay.”
James thrusts again and again. “God, I love fucking you.”
Then he pauses and grunts as Cas thrusts into him from behind.
“Oh yes, God,” Caroline moans. “Fuck us both, Cas.”
And he does.
His thrusts drive James into Caroline and I feel every pounding stroke, too.
We’re all connected.
I play with her nipples. We take turns telling her how gorgeous she is, how good she is, how much we love her, how this is just the start of things between us all, and then James says, “Rub her clit, Grayson. Make her come again.”
“I’m so close,” she says, her voice ragged as the back of her head presses into my chest.
I reach between her and James and find her clit. The sensation of James fucking into her and my hand adds to the heat of it and I circle her clit then pinch it, and just like that, she’s crying out and coming apart.
James stiffens and empties into her a moment later, then Cas shouts James’s name and comes as well.
Everyone collapses onto the bed, a tangle of limbs and heavy breathing.
Caroline is draped over my chest. Cas is curled around James. James’s hand is splayed over Caroline’s hip.
