AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Then Came You

Page 97

by Kora Nyx

“I’m sorry,” I sigh, running my hands through my thick hair and tucking it behind my ears. “I know that’s not fair.”

He smiles wistfully, and I’ve got to say, I love that he doesn’t immediately go on the defensive or order me out of his house for even suggesting such a thing.

Instead, he surprises me again like he has at every turn. “I’m so sorry if I made you feel that way for even a second.”

Another wash of guilt sweeps through me, and I’m about to reiterate that I don’t actually think that, I’m just all mixed up and confused, when he continues:

“And you must know, you are anything but ordinary. You absolutely sparkle in a world of the truly dullest people.”

My knee-jerk response is to tell him again not to bullshit me, but before I can, he’s going on.

“I should know.” His hands lightly pat his chest. “I’m one of them. We’re boring and so fucking predictable, it’s painful. We do exactly what everybody expects of us. We wake up and mostly hate our lives but we’ve been doing what was expected of us for so damn long, we forgot there was any other way to live.”

He half rises out of his seat before stopping himself and sitting back down. But it looks like it takes a lot of restraint to stay put and not come to me.

“Please understand. You’re the most extraordinary woman I’ve ever met. And I really, really want to pursue something more with you.”

His face falls. “But my ex-wife is not a well woman. The custody battle is going to end up back in the courts. No doubt about it. Her family has resources and has never played fair. If she were an adequate parent, I wouldn’t be up in arms.”

“But she’s not,” I finish for him, feeling my stomach twist in on itself. “She’s not a good mother.”

Slowly, and with clear devastation on his face, he shakes his head. “No, she’s not. I worry about Ella in that environment and about the fact that Kayla has still been harboring delusions of getting back together with me.”

I feel my eyes widen. Shit.

He scrubs a hand down his face. “But it’s even worse than that. There’s a clause in our custody order about no overnight guests I’m romantically involved with being around while Ella’s in the house. I’ve gotten you caught in the middle of it without even meaning to,” he admits, his face ashen.

I nod.

Then I stand up and smooth my hands down the thighs of my jeans.

“Well that makes it all so much more devastating, doesn’t it?”

“What?” Marcus asks, eyes begging me not to say what comes next.

What has to come next.

“We can’t see each other anymore.”

He nods, expelling a long, pained-sounding breath. “I understand. We have to put Ella first.”

It’s true. But also… “I have to take care of me, too, for once. And Marcus, while I don’t want to drop out of Ella’s life completely, because I would never just disappear on her, I don’t think it’s right for me to continue on as her nanny, either.”

“What?” he shoots to his feet. “Why not? If we aren’t pursuing anything between us, there’s no impropriety⁠—”

“Kayla’s still Ella’s mother,” I say, tears gathering at my eyes. “It’s not respectful of me to stay here when she vehemently doesn’t want me living under the same roof as her daughter. Not when you’re still in a custody battle and it could affect the outcome of the case.”

Marcus’s entire body sags.

Because he knows I’m right.

“So both of us lose you?” The heartbreak in his voice is enough to break me, too. “Just like that?”

My chin wobbles as I shrug. “I don’t know the future, Marcus. But I know I’ll never forget what you said about me sparkling and being anything other than ordinary. Because no one’s ever truly seen me before, except for maybe my Aunt Dani. I always thought I was invisible compared to my sister, but you’ve just made me feel so seen. And for the record, I think you’re pretty damn special, too, Marcus Reyes.”

The tears I’ve been holding back finally spill down my cheeks. “I’ve never met a man like you, either. Thank you for proving to me what is possible.”

He swallows hard, and for a second our gazes lock, the room heavy with all it feels like is burning on the tip of his tongue.