AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Then Came You

Page 71

by Kora Nyx

It mostly works. Whenever my brain tries to replay that second across the table, I force myself to listen to what the host is saying. Whenever I remember Marcus’s eyes dropping toward my mouth, I remind myself I could have imagined it.

By the time I’m halfway home, I’ve almost convinced myself the entire interaction was nothing.

Good God. What was I thinking?

Instead, I refocus on Will. I imagine his surprise when he finally hears my voicemail. Maybe I’ll stop at the little Thai place near the library and bring him something after I check on Claudia. Maybe he’ll be tired and I’ll rub his shoulders while he tells me about whatever impossible research problem has consumed his week.

That’s real. That’s the man I’m with.

By the time I pull into the second parking space outside my apartment, I’ve mostly talked myself down from the ledge.

But then, bass pounding from my second-story apartment reaches me before I even get out of the car.

I sigh because, of course, Claudia has music thumping loudly enough that I can feel the vibration faintly through the stair railing once I start climbing. It’s almost nine o’clock, and it wouldn’t be the first time the neighbors have complained since she moved in.

At least loud music means she’s probably not passed out drunk somewhere. I tell myself that counts as a win.

The blinds are closed, but shifting blue light from the television flickers through a crooked gap in one of them. As I reach the landing and dig my key from my purse, I decide I won’t lead with therapy or drinking or anything else that might make her shut down.

Maybe I’ll suggest pizza and see where the night goes. If it feels right, I can tell her I found a couple of therapists and let her decide whether she wants the information. There doesn’t have to be pressure. I can just be her sister.

The lock catches the way it always does, and I shoulder the sticky door open.

The music gets instantly louder.

I’m about to call out her name when I notice a pair of men’s shoes kicked sideways near the couch. I barely have time to register them before I look up.

My sister is spread wide-legged across the couch, and there’s a man’s ass pumping between her thighs.

For one stupid second, my brain refuses to process what I’m looking at.

“Claudia!” I yelp as I start to cover my eyes and turn away.

Then the man jerks around at the sound of my voice and the world stops.

It’s Will.

My Will.

For one second, his face blurs with another one from ten years ago. I’m suddenly remembering a different room and another boyfriend turning toward me with Claudia underneath him. The same sick drop opens in my stomach before the present snaps back into focus.

And I’m standing here again, looking at Will fucking my sister in my apartment.

Will stumbles backward away from the couch, his still-half-hard dick swinging obscenely as he swears and grabs for his pants. He’s not wearing a condom. He nearly loses his balance. It would be comical if my world weren’t crashing in on itself.

Claudia doesn’t scramble to cover herself.

She doesn’t even look ashamed. Quite the opposite, in fact.

She looks directly at me and smirks.

My stomach drops even farther because that look is worse than the sex. That look tells me she knows exactly what this is doing to me.

Will is still fumbling on the floor for the rest of his clothes, but Claudia never breaks eye contact. “Not so high and mighty now, are you, sister?”

For a second, I can’t breathe.

Miss High and Mighty.