Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer
Page 14
“You did. You stated it for the record.” He opens his eyes, a smirk on his face. He looks at me, and there’s a moment where I could say something, but I feel it come and go just as quickly.
Alex cups my face and places the softest kiss on my lips. Thankfully, he doesn’t push it too far, choosing to pull away after just a moment.
“The hearing… The Deputy Director role.”
“Okay,” he breathes, his forehead against mine. “It’s all going to be okay,” he promises quietly. “I’ll wait until after to talk about this. I’ll wait until you’re ready.”
I don’t say anything. I don’t know if I can.
The train is up and running by eight. We take it back in silence, side by side on the orange seats, my binder resting on my knees and the car full of Sunday-morning people in puffer coats.
Neither one of us says much the entire ride. For my career’s sake, I’ve chosen to push this lapse in judgment out of my head at least until the day after the board’s decision is made, a plan Alex seems to have tacitly agreed to. Right now, I cannot be the girl who let a crush on a guy ruin her future. I’ve worked too hard for this.
By Queensboro Plaza, I feel more like myself again. Alex goes back to calling me Santana and I’m back to keeping things all business.
“We should divide the affidavits by argument, not by family,” I tell him in my counsel voice.
Alex looks out the subway window and replies with a quiet, “Sure.”
Just like that, he lets me pretend that last night—and early this morning—never happened. I can feel him deciding, somewhere between Hunters Point and Grand Central, not to reach across the seat and take my hand like he did this morning before I sat up and left him alone in bed. I can feel him fighting against the urge to bring up how he felt last night. I can feel him battling against his basic instincts and giving me the space I need to process it all. And while I tell myself that’s what I want, I watch him look out the window at the snow on the rail yards and realize I hate every second of it.
The emergency motion is Monday at ten, before judge Adeyemi, in a courtroom on the fourth floor of Queens Housing Court that smells like radiators and wet coats and has, on the clerk’s window, a single straw of tinsel somebody has taped up in what looks like an act of institutional defiance.
Alex and I are prepped and ready to take on this case, but I’m still nervous. Not because I don’t think we can win this case, but because how it’s been handled will determine the course of my career. Whether I stay at the NYCIJC or not. Whether I need to leave and find a place where I can grow and reach my potential. Whether I see Alex on the regular again or start leading a life I haven’t know since before law school. Because if one of us leaves because the other becomes their boss—
But I can’t think of that now. I need to think only of the information in my binder, of the eleven families, and the asshole landlord who wants nothing more than to ruin a building’s holidays.
The landlord’s lawyer is a man named Pruett who has the tan of someone who bills his clients for it. In his early fifties, he stinks of narcissism and self-importance, and I can barely handle it. I look to my right at Alex, watching him watch the attorney with the same disdain I feel, and smile.
I like that about him—that even though he’s my toughest competition, we both stand for the same things. That we’re passionate about what’s good and fair, and will fight our own coworkers over it.
“Your honor, respondent’s motion papers were served on my clients former registered agent,” Pruett starts. “The new agent was filed with the Department of State on December fourth. Petitioner has no objection to a hearing on the merits, but on this record, respectfully, there’s no personal jurisdiction over the current owner for purposes of the emergency application.”
I feel it happen. I feel the floor go. I know before Judge Adeyemi looks at me over her glasses that he’s right, that the ownership transfer went through a shell, that the new LLC filed a new agent four days after the deed, and just a few days before my process server walked into an office on Queens Boulevard and handed my papers to a receptionist who took them without a word. I know because I checked—I checked the deed, I checked the LLC, I checked the tax rolls—and I did not check the Department of State a second time, on Thursday, the day I filed, because I was standing in the copy room under mistletoe dying to be kissed by a man I thought I hated.
“Ms. Santana?”
“Your Honor.” My voice is fine. My tone is level and unshakable. I’ve trained for this. No matter what, I won’t let them see me sweat. “Respondent would ask Court to deem service sufficient given the emergency nature of the—”
“I can’t do that, counsel, and you know that.” She’s not unkind—which might be worse, if I’m honest. “Serve the right agent, Ms. Santana. You can refile. I’ll hear you on the boiler with the holdover on the twenty-second, and if the heat’s not on by then Mr. Pruett, your client and I are going to have a different conversation. Motion denied without prejudice. Next case.”
Forty-eight hours. The clerk gives us forty-eight hours to refile with proper service, and the twenty-second, which was always the hearing, will now be about the boiler, too. It’s everything. And the only thing that’s going to be in front of that judge is whatever we put together by Wednesday.
***
I say it at the four o’clock meeting.
The whole floor’s there. Constance at the head, Priya, Daniel, the fellows, the paralegals—and even the intake volunteers who are only here because it’s the meeting before the party and there are cookies. Somebody’s put a Santa hat on the coat rack, and Mariah is coming faintly through the wall from the lobby.
“The OSC was denied on service,” I say. “That’s on me. I checked the agent on the fourth, and I didn’t recheck it before our hearing. Pruett had it in his pocket the entire time.” I don’t look at Alex, but I force myself to look at Constance, feeling shame spread through my system. “We have until Wednesday at five to refile, and there’s no point filing the OSC alone. Judge Adeyemi’s hearing everything on the twenty-second. So what goes in front of her on the twenty-second is the consolidated answer. All eleven families, all eleven affidavits, and the pattern argument. That’s the case now.”
There’s a pause which I can hear the Mariah song hitting a high note.
“That was Alex’s strategy,” I say, conceding. “From the first meeting. He was right about the pattern, and he was right that a judge would want to see all of it. And I said we’d get adjourned into January and I was wrong. If we win this, we win on his answer.”
I have never in my life said the words I was wrong and Alex in the same sentence in front of another human being. The entire room knows it.
Daniel’s hand moves toward his phone to make note of this loss on the chart, I’m sure. But Priya, without looking, puts her hand flat on top of it to stop him.