Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer
Page 11
The heater rattles, the snow hits the window, and the silence between us grows heavy with all the million things we’ve left unsaid.
“Last December,” she murmurs.
I close my eyes and nod, knowing where she’s going with this. Where we should’ve gone months ago.
“On the fire escape. You said—about the closing. The Ortiz closing. You said you’d never seen anyone do it better.” Her voice is careful and even, in the way that it is when she’s walking a witness up to the edge of a big revelation. “I thought you were just being a good guy. That you were being nice. I’d lost that other case that fall. And I thought you saw me out there and felt sorry for me. And then I laughed and stood there too long and Daniel opened the door and I thought, good, he’ll never have to let me down easy now.”
I turn to face her now, my breath catching. “You thought I was being nice.”
“You’re—” She stops, a rough exhale. “Yes. You’re nice. You’re nice and kind in Spanish to eighty-one-year-old women and you order two dinners and pretend it was a mistake and you know where Nadia keeps the vacuum and are so damn smart, and I’ve spent seven years telling myself that was just what you were like. That it wasn’t for me. You’ve never been for me, Alex.”
A laugh breaks through me—I’m shocked. “I’ve always been yours.” I say it with conviction, leaving her with no room for reasonable doubt.
“Alex—”
“I’ve been yours since October of first year of law school.” I stand up, even though I have no idea what the next words coming out of my mouth will be—just that I need to come clean. “I said that about your closing because it was true, and because I’d been standing at the bar that night for an hour trying to think of a single fucking thing I could say to you that wouldn’t end in a debate or an argument. And you laughed. And I thought you were being nice and kind to me.”
Marisol looks at the paper in her hands. She looks at me. And then she laughs—not her real one, not yet—and says, “But what about all the fighting and—”
I shake my head with a groan. “Just my idiocy. I loved competing with you because it made me a better lawyer and person. You set such a high standard. That, and then I realized if we weren’t fighting, you barely noticed me, and I really needed you to notice me, Marisol. I—”
“That’s not true,” she cuts me off.
“What’s not true?”
“I noticed you. You infuriated me, but I wasn’t… I wasn’t immune to how smart or… good-looking you are. You’re just…”
“Infuriating?” I smile, taking a step closer to her.
“Yeah,” she whispers, smiling back. She looks at the paper in her hands and folds it, handing it back to me. With great care, I tuck it into my wallet before slipping it back into my pocket.
“I really like you, Marisol. And I am so, so sorry I’ve not been able to show it properly.”
“I—” She hesitates, looking between my eyes as if she’s just been hit by this harsh realization. “I think I really like you, too? I don’t know when it happened, exactly. But yeah, I think I like you.”
I exhale a laugh, running my fingers through my hair.
“You think?”
“This is very new. I think I have some mental paperwork to do.”
I smirk. “Sorry for the extra work.”
“I’ll send you the bill.” But she smirks, taking another step toward me. My heart takes off on a sprint, and I’m loving that she’s so close I could count the freckles on her nose, notice the kaleidoscope of golds and browns and caramels in her eyes.
We laugh softly, and it feels good having this off my chest. Maybe now we can take this somewhere. Or at the very least there could be peace. And that sounds like heaven because I am so tired of fighting her and fighting this.
“I mean, I liked you at the holiday party, but then everything else this year happened and…”
“Yeah.” I sigh. “You’ve been extra hard on me lately.”
“I was embarrassed. I thought I’d been rejected and, I don’t know,” she says, looking away. “It was wrong of me. But you were intense, too, challenging me on everything all the damn time.”
“I like to challenge you.”
“Ugh, I think I like being challenged by you?” she says, almost unable to believe it herself.
I laugh and shake my head at the craziness of it all. “We’re not great at this, are we?” I reach for her hand and pull her closer, letting her take the last few steps into me. When she does, sliding her hands up my chest, fingers locking around my neck, I nearly melt. Feeling her pressed up like me is fucking heaven, her scent filling my brain, making me dizzy.