Page 45
DO NOT ANSWER: But don’t leave your phone unattended, or you may find yourself with a rogue dating profile too.
I hold the phone for a few seconds, considering, then admit—
I already have a dating profile.
So naturally I looked at yours, PineDaddy.
DO NOT ANSWER: That’s PineDaddy4U, thank you very much.
[Laughter emoji]
Will you sing a Christmas carol for all to hear if I come?
DO NOT ANSWER: Yes. I’ll even let you choose which one
I’ll be there soon.
And I’ll Be Home for Christmas. That’s the song I want.
DO NOT ANSWER: Nice callback.
Truth be told, that song’s been in my head since he left the bookstore whistling it a few months ago.
THIRTEEN
MILES
The nonnas have long since gone to bed, but my siblings and I are outside celebrating with the Cafiero kids. We’re sitting on a couple of patchwork blankets on the ground outside the apple barn, passing around jugs of cider and flasks of whiskey, when Emily’s car pulls up.
I perk up like a dog who’s heard the rustle of the treat bag.
My sister gives me a sidelong glance as I offer Emily the sweatshirt I set aside for her. I grin like an idiot when she accepts it, and my smile grows wider when I pat the space next to me and she actually sits there. Admittedly, she’s between me and Bianca, but it feels like a victory.
We’re close enough that her shoulder brushes mine when she shifts, and the buzz of conversation seems to hush, each tiny movement between us louder than the words.
Maybe Emily feels that way too, because she barely says anything until Giovanni’s sister starts making a fuss about wanting to sing carols.
Bianca and I point out it’s a Murphy family tradition to wait until midnight, and Emily finally looks straight at me. “But Miles promised he’d serenade us with the first Christmas carol of the season.”
“Nope,” Bianca says, adamantly shaking her head. “It’s Thanksgiving until midnight. It’s unlucky to break the rule. Miles calls it the Christmas Carol curse.”
I do indeed, and I never let anyone break the family rule. At the same time, I know how important keeping promises is to Emily. If she wants the first song of the season before midnight, she’s damn well going to get it.
“I did promise her I’d embarrass myself,” I tell Bianca. “That old lady seeing me on Bumble wasn’t enough for her. Emily will only settle for full-on mortification. I have to keep my promise, curse or no curse.”
Emily’s fighting a smile, thank God.
“There’s crap spouting up in our tree stand,” Theo adds, reacting to Bianca’s dubious expression. “I don’t know how much more cursed we can get.”
I shift my gaze back to Emily. “Why don’t we find out?”
Bianca’s giving me a pointed look, but I ignore her. She created that fake dating profile, so she deserves to be ignored. May all her pies be bland, may all her stockings have coal in them.
Then I start belting out “I’ll Be Home for Christmas,” getting up and raising my arms in the direction of the firs, visible from here but only just. Nearly everyone joins me, except for Emily, who stays seated.
I stop mid-chorus and reach out a hand to her. “Come on, Emily. Let’s serenade the trees before we chop them down. It’s their last hurrah. You don’t want to take their last hurrah away from them.”
She smiles but doesn’t move, her expression thoughtful as she watches me in the dark.