AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 28

by Angela Casella

DO NOT ANSWER: Please meet me tonight.

DO NOT ANSWER: I just want to talk.

OK, but I don’t want us to be overheard.

You can come to my apartment above the shop. Use the back staircase. 7 p.m.

DO NOT ANSWER: So I got upgraded to an apartment visit?

Don’t read too much into it.

DO NOT ANSWER: I’m reading into it, Emily…

Drunk butterflies try to take flight in my stomach. For a second, I wonder at them—I’ve read about this feeling, but until now I’ve never fully experienced it. It’s disarming and not as pleasant as I’d imagined. At the same time, it’s exciting.

Still, I clap those imaginary insects down the way they deserve.

Miles is OFF-LIMITS, all caps, and he must be kept at arm’s length at all costs.

I have to deal with this situation before it becomes a problem, and I’ve spent the last few hours half-heartedly forming a plan.

Still, even though this is not a date or an assignation or anything that requires me to look fancy, I head to my shoebox bathroom to freshen up before he arrives. I pull on a different sweater, more flattering to my complexion, and line my eyes with black, telling myself I’m not dressing up for him. This is no different than a female warrior preparing to battle a dragon.

Or parlay with her much-too-handsome enemy.

Then I make another pot of cinnamon apple tea and prepare a plate of pumpkin cookies before I start pacing the tiny space, almost feverish with worry. I’m still pacing when Miles knocks out the familiar call-and-response knock.

Instead of knocking back, I open it.

Our gazes meet, and then mine skips down to the burning feather on his arm. A bolt of heat consumes me, as if I’ve swallowed the feather.

Miles is carrying a to-go container, which he holds out to me.

“I brought you pie. Now, I know you’re going to expect it to be the winning pie, but the mayor cheated, so fuck him. This is Giovanni’s pie, and we both know⁠—”

I tug him inside and close the door behind him.

His gaze pings around my apartment. “So this is where the magic happens.”

“No magic is happening tonight,” I say as I accept the pie from him. “Would you like some tea?”

He holds my gaze for a moment before nodding. “How about I pour it?”

“Okay,” I say, my throat tight.

My hands are trembling too hard for me to pour it without burning myself anyway, and the look in his eyes says he knows it.

He’s uncharacteristically silent as I stuff the pie into the refrigerator and he pours tea into the waiting pottery cups.

The tea set was an extravagant purchase for a woman who doesn’t have many visitors and is saving every penny, but I spotted it in the window at East Fork Pottery on a trip to Asheville and my heart filled with yearning. I’d imagined having a little house someday, all my own, and gathering Luanne and the other Golden Apples there instead of the antiseptic-smelling rec room at the retirement home.

It’s one of my foolish fancies, but it hasn’t released its hold.

In my heart, all I’ve ever wanted is a home.

“Let’s sit,” I say, but I wait until Miles lowers onto the couch first so I can leave plenty of space between us.

He’s watching me with those strange, sensual eyes, and I push a little closer to him without intending to.