Page 129
“But what if this happened because we left?” I cried, unable to be strong for anyone. God Belle was my world. I would give my life for her. I didn’t know how to be anything but frightened.
“Phoenix, no.” His voice was firm, but never harsh. “You didn’t do this.”
“She’s your daughter.” I pressed my free hand against my mouth, trying to stop myself from crying.
“She’s your baby, too.” The words hit me harder than I thought they would. Everything stilled inside me as I turned to him, unsure of what it meant or the gravity of those words.
He went silent for half a second, then he brought my hand to his mouth and kissed my knuckles. “We’re going to find her.” His voice was steady enough to hold onto, even though I could see the fear in his eyes whenever he glanced at me. “I don’t care what happened, I don’t care how long it takes. We are bringing our baby home, it’s that simple.”
I nodded, crying harder now as I leaned against the seat, whispering apologies I knew he didn’t want to hear, and prayers I hoped went straight into God’s ears. Cassian kept one hand on mine whenever he could, reminding me without words that I wasn’t alone in the terror swallowing me whole.
By the time we reached his parents’ house, night had settled over everything, and the lights inside the house made the scene somehow more frightening. Everyone was there, his parents were waiting near the entrance, his mother’s face beyond pale with worry, and his father stood beside her with the kind of stillness that told me he was barely holding himself together. Nikolai was pacing across the living room, phone pressed against his ear, while Alaric stood near the windows with his arms folded tightly across his chest. Nadia was beside him, her eyes red, and expression strained. The moment Cassian walked through the door, Nikolai lowered the phone.
“Nothing,” he said. One word, and it seemed to suck all the air from the room.
Cassian stopped. “Nothing?”
Nikolai shook his head. “We’re still looking. I’ve got people checking every route from the house, the surrounding streets, everywhere she could have gone. Security is pulling footage now.”
“How long?” Cassian’s face tightened. “We’ve been looking since we realized she wasn’t where she was supposed to be.”
I stood frozen, my heart pounding so hard it hurt. “What happened?” I finally asked, barely managing the words.
Nadia turned to me, guilt in her eyes as fresh tears began to fall. No, she shouldn’t blame herself, though it looked like she had been doing that all day.
“I… we… I took her to the store. I wanted to buy her things before you guys returned… we…” She stopped, crying hard and it broke me. “I swear she was right there. I saw her, she was laughing about beads and I…”
“My dear…” Mr. Vanderhart called as Nikolai walked towards her.
Before he could reach her, I pulled her into my embrace, hugging her while we both broke down.
“It’s not your fault. We’ll find her,” I assured her, trying my best to hold her as we both shook.
“I don’t know, I… God what have I done?” she cried. “I’m so sorry. I’m so sorry, Cassian. I wouldnt… I didn’t…”
“It’s okay,” I said, holding her while she cried her guilt and fear out.
“What do I do?” she asked as her tears finally ran dry.
“Let us find her. Go get some rest,” Alaric suggested, turning to us. “You too, Aria.”
“We want to be here, we can’t rest.” I turned to Nadia, who only nodded aggressively, agreeing with me.
“We’ve called everyone. Her school, her friends, the neighbors. No one has seen her,” Mrs Vanderhart said next, her voice trembling.
Cassian stepped farther into the room, dragging both hands over his face before looking at his brothers. “I don’t understand,” he said, his voice breaking for the first time. “How could this happen? Who would dare do this?”
Nikolai looked down at the phone in his hand. “Cass...”
Cassian shook his head, unable to finish the thought. His father moved toward him and placed a hand on his shoulder, while his mother cried quietly beside Nadia and I. As I stood there among all of them, watching a family that had always seemed so impossibly strong come apart around the empty space Belle had left behind, I felt the guilt settle even deeper in my chest. I knew Cassian had told me it wasn’t my fault, and I knew he meant it, but watching his face, watching him try to hold himself together for everyone else… I couldn’t stop thinking that somehow, somewhere, I had brought this darkness with me.
Chapter Fifty-Six
Aria
As the pacing continued, so did the calls and the yelling. Chaos unfolded, and by midnight the house was filled with cops, detectives, everyone and anyone, really. The news was filled with Belle’s pictures and her last known whereabouts. It was like a movie unfolding before us, a movie none of us wanted to be in.
As I watched the cops talk to Nadia and Nikolai, my phone rang and I froze for half a second when I saw the unknown number on the screen, then looked away and let it ring. My nerves were already stretched too thin, and I didn’t want to deal with another stranger asking questions while Belle was missing. The ringing stopped, and I exhaled shakily and tried to focus on the conversation around me. Then it rang again, the same number. I stared at it this time, my stomach tightening for reasons I couldn’t explain, before I turned the phone facedown and ignored it again.