AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Fatal Prospect

Page 52

by Elizabeth Barone

Olivia

Iride out to The Beanery, a hole in the wall coffee shop that’s been in downtown Waterbury for decades. It’s annoying that Cami picked a place out of town, but I get it. I wouldn’t want to be seen with me, either. Not with my reputation.

I stroll through the door, lifting a hand in greeting to a blonde barista I don’t recognize. I used to ride the bus out here during high school, always on my own. This was my spot. Not even Greg knew about it. I liked that it was out of town, that no one here recognized me. It was my escape.

Behind the counter, a guy wearing a backward baseball cap holds a phone between his ear and shoulder. He isn’t the owner, but they’ve got the same nose, just younger. So much has changed since I was last here.

I spot Vaughn and Cami at a table tucked into a corner, and sigh. I’m going to need something stronger than coffee.

“What can I get you?” the barista asks. She’s perky but there’s an edge to her, a fraying around her eyes.

“Give me your strongest drink in your biggest size,” I tell her. “And no pumpkin anything.”

“So, a nitro. Except I can’t give it to you in anything bigger than a medium. It’s that strong,” she says with a wink.

“Do it.” I turn away while she makes my coffee, pouring it from a tap like at a bar. I try not to watch Cami—not in an obvious way, anyway—but I can’t help it. She still looks whole. Her blue eyes crinkle at something Vaughn says, her lips tipping upward in a smile. There aren’t any dark circles under her eyes. No signs of nightmares that keep her awake.

I watch as Vaughn leans into her, his dark eyes intent on whatever it is she’s saying. They’re so comfortable sitting there. By walking over, I’ll ruin it all.

I almost tell the barista to make my drink to go. Then Vaughn spots me and jerks his chin at me. Sighing, I take the nitro she holds out to me and traipse over to them.

“Vaughn. Cami.” I don’t know what else to say. “Hi” seems a little too chipper, considering. I’ve never been a chipper girl.

“Hi Olivia,” she says. Of course she’s a chipper girl. She’s still shiny.

Vaughn slides over a seat, motioning for me to sit where he just was. This puts me directly across from Cami. I chuckle nervously, setting my nitro down. An awkward moment passes as I stand here.

That’s when I notice the shiner he’s sporting.

“Dude, what happened to you?”

“Ah, it’s nothing,” he says with a smirk.

Cami’s cheeks turn pink, and I tilt my head at the two of them.

“I won’t bite,” she promises, avoiding him and glancing at the open seat.

“Olivia might,” Vaughn jokes.

Even though it’s at my expense, it snaps me back into the moment. I pull the chair out and sit. This close to Cami, I can see the details I missed from way back there: the way her clothes hang on her a little, the tightness at the corners of her eyes, the slight tremor to her hands.

“Thanks for coming,” I say, because what else can I say? “I thought you skipped town.”

“I did,” she says on a long exhale. “After what you told me, I panicked.” Her bright blue eyes cloud over a bit. “I always knew something was off about Greg. Another one of his exes said something similar to what you said, and there were a couple times he got a little rough with me.” She swallows. “So I ran,” she finishes.

“But you came back,” Vaughn says. His hand slides toward her then halts.

I smirk, then quickly pull my face back into neutral. I can’t wait to bust his balls about this later.

“I came back,” she affirms, but she doesn’t elaborate. I don’t push, because it’s none of my business, and it isn’t what I came here for.

“Cami, we thought you might be able to help us with something.” I spin my cup around.

“That’s what Vaughn said. I don’t know what I can possibly do to repay you, but I’ll try.”

I blink at her. “Repay me?”

She nods, but again, she doesn’t say any more about it. “So what’s this about?”