AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Lost Stepson

Page 50

by Annie Moon

I tweak his chin, letting my index finger skim along the edge of his lower lip. Alijah’s tongue comes out, I think it’s automatic because he surprises himself and then sucks it back in again. “I remember everything about you, Alijah.”

Alijah leans toward me and I’m tempted to meet him halfway just the way we did when he came down the stairway earlier. But I’m aware of Nate and I back away.

“Well, anyway…” Nate says, nerves seeming to cause the stutter when he says, “Yeah, so have a happy birthday.”

“Thank you,” Alijah says and tugs at my sleeve. “Henry sent me to get you.”

“Good night, Nate.” As soon as I close the garage door, I’m intensely aware that I’m alone with Alijah for the first time all evening.

God, there are so many things going through my head that are terribly dirty…but also, tender and intimate. I reach out and sift my fingers through his silky hair. “I know we have to go inside before Henry comes for us…” But instead of moving, I tug him closer by his hair, which startles him as he looks at me with wide eyes. When his mouth is inches from nine, I murmur, “Happy birthday, ballerina,” and I press a gentle kiss to his lips, tasting strawberries and the sweet flavor of him. Then I open the door to the hallway, my sweet boy still in shock from our intimate connection, however chaste. I gesture for him to go ahead of me as we join our waiting friends and family.

Zane selects a playlist of instrumental tunes from his library of both piano and guitar, which provide ambient background when there is a lull in the conversation. Zane also proved them perfect for slow dancing as he held out his hand to Hugo and led him into the spacious foyer.

After a few minutes, Alijah jumps up from the sofa and presses Stop on Zane’s phone. “Not fair, since the three of us aren’t going to get cozy and do a slow dance. But we can do this,” he chants and brings up “One More Time,” a ’90s song by Daft Punk, on his phone. “Come on you two,” he says to Henry and me. “Dance with me.”

And so, we do, following Alijah’s lead. I’m not an awful dancer and when I let myself feel the beat, I can hold my own. Not anything like Alijah, whose luscious curves and swaying hips make my mouth water. But I refuse to let my wayward dick ruin the high everyone is on. With Zane’s encouragement and his hands on my brother’s hips, Hugo lets go.

We laugh, bump, and grind across the wooden floor as one song segues into the next. After four, however, Zane and Alijah are the only two left.

“This is when you know you’re old,” Hugo says to me.

Henry, who is turning forty-seven this year, groans his agreement as we continue to watch the much younger men. “They’re sexy together.”

“I was going to say gorgeous,” my brother says. “But yeah, same thing.” And then he peers at me, his blue eyes dulling with confusion. In a low, stressed tone, he asks, “What am I doing, Enzo?”

Zane is next to my brother in an instant. Grabbing Hugo’s wrist, he yanks him to his feet and presses him close. He whispers something I don’t hear but makes Hugo lower his eyelashes and smile. “You’re going to help me put the candles on the birthday cake. That is…as long as you don’t mind, Enzo?”

“No, while you do that, Henry and I will make room on the table and put out the cake plates.” We’d cleared the dirty dishes and cutlery earlier and had very little leftovers to store. The dinner of appetizers was scrumptious, with choices like individual portions of lobster mac and cheese, mussels marinara, and steak tartare.

As soon as the table is ready, Henry fiddles with his camera lens and starts shooting as I hold out my hand to Alijah. “Come on over, birthday boy.”

Alijah turns up his nose at me. “I’m not a boy.”

And oh, how I crave to make him believe that he is my boy—a beautiful, pristine man that I long to dirty and take apart. Yes, to Hugo’s comment, the age gap is insane. And yet, for all his doubt about being with Zane, he melts into the young man’s touches like honey in hot tea.

I smile at Alijah as Hugo comes out of the kitchen carrying the cake, moving slowly so the candles don’t go out. Zane is at his side and when the cake is safely in front of Alijah, we all sing happy birthday.

Alijah seems close to tears and when he attempts to blow out the candles, he splutters and manages to croak out, “Help me.”

We all do and when they’re snuffed out, Hugo hands the knife to Alijah to make the first slice. “Sorry, for getting emotional. But I’m so grateful to have the two most important men in my life with me. And two new men, who I’m sure will become significant in my life as well. Thank you.”

The knife slices through easily and as Alijah takes the first bite he moans, a sound so erotic I have to sit down. Otherwise, my erection is sure to tent my pants.

As it turns out, we all sit at the table in lovely stillness. Until…Alijah catches my attention, licks his spoon like a lollypop as he peeks at me while Hugo is talking to Zane. The brat has the audacity to stick out his chocolate-covered tongue. I palm my cock under the table and squeeze hard enough for it to deflate slightly.

But thankfully, after the cake, our energy diminishes, everyone is sated and lightly buzzed from champagne and wine flowing consistently. Henry is the only one who drank very little, explaining that the cost of his camera is a month’s mortgage payment and he doesn’t risk dropping it from inebriation.

I’m putting away the cake when Hugo comes into the kitchen. “Hey, everything all right?” I stop what I’m doing and give him my full attention.

“Not really. I’m jealous that you gave Alijah the birthday party that I never did. And I’m struggling with not letting my distorted emotions sour my relationship with you. You did a great job, and my feelings are on me.”

“I love you, Hugo. We’ll be fine.”

Rubbing his palms together, he says, “I’m going to ask Alijah to come home with me even though I already know the answer. His fixation on you is clear every time he looks at you. I also see you being a gentleman, which I appreciate. But only you know if your composure is genuine or a show for me. So, I’m reminding you, Enzo. He’s my stepson. Don’t touch him or I will sever our relationship for good.”

Any notion I had about Hugo having relaxed his stance about me is obliterated by his warning. He sees my attraction to Alijah as solely sexual, and not the feelings of a man who’s been obsessed with his ballerina since the beginning. I use a different tactic. “Doesn’t Alijah have a say in who he interacts with?”

“I’m not merely talking about interaction,” Hugo hisses. “And you damn well know it.”