Page 80
I don’t remember the last time I was this nervous. If ever.
Yet here I am, one hand clutching a bouquet of flowers and the other holding my skates. My feet won’t stop moving in a nervous shuffle as I wait for Sutton to arrive.
Once I came up with the idea—and Theo gave it a rave review—I texted her to confirm that we were still a go and asked what time would be good for me to pick her up. I was a little let down when she asked if she could meet me because her sister had some sort of wedding emergency she needed Sutton’s help with. And since she had to take Maverick to Rob’s anyway, she couldn’t say no to her sister.
Honestly, it was probably better I didn’t drive her. I could feel my hands shaking on the steering wheel the entire way here. The problem with me not driving her, though? I got here thirty minutes early. And instead of waiting in my car, I’ve decided to stand at the entrance, pacing back and forth like I did on draft night.
“Can I do this, Hailey?” I whisper to myself as I walk back and forth. “I know you’d want me to. And I know you’re probably yelling at me because I wore the same jeans I’ve owned for five years. But I don’t know if I can do this. I know this isn’t a real date. But…it feels real. And weird. And different. And—”
The sound of an engine gets my attention as I see headlights turning into the parking lot. I don’t know if it’s a sign from Hailey telling me to suck it up, or coincidental timing, but either way, the car is Sutton’s, and it’s go time.
Just breathe.
This is just to get to know her a little better.
This isn’t real.
I wonder how many times I’m going to have to remind myself of that tonight. Because as I watch Sutton walk toward me, I find myself having a little trouble breathing, and a lot of trouble remembering that last one.
She’s wearing a fitted black T-shirt that’s somehow sexier on her than the dress she wore to the engagement party. She paired it with black leggings and has a yellow and black flannel tied around her waist. Her red hair is down—something else I’ve never seen on her before—and the setting sun is reflecting off her hair, making her look like she’s actually glowing.
I knew she was an attractive woman. I’ve known that since the first time I saw her. But here? Now? She’s…beautiful.
“Sorry I’m late,” she says. “I kept trying to leave and suddenly ten other things popped up that Angelina just had to go over with me.”
“You’re fine,” I say as I step up to her, swallowing the sudden frog in my throat. “Did you find the place okay?”
“I did,” she says, a curious look crossing her face. “But an ice rink? I can confidently say I’ve never been to a first date here.”
I relax a little at her teasing. “Well, I told you this night was for us to get to know each other better. Be able to answer questions I’m sure people are going to ask us. And since I wasn’t sure what was an appropriate first date with your fake girlfriend, but I knew you liked hockey, my first thought was to take you to a game.”
“Kind of hard to go on a date to a game when one half of that date is playing.”
“Exactly,” I say as I hold the door open for her. “So I thought this was the next best thing.”
We walk into the rink and, just as I suspected, there are only a few families skating around. Thank goodness for summer months and a Monday night.
“You’re taking me ice skating?”
Her question hits me in the pit of my stomach. Shit, have I fucked this up already? “Is that okay? I just thought—”
She stops and turns to me, putting her hand over my rapidly beating heart. “It’s amazing. I should warn you about something though.”
“What’s that?”
“I don’t know how to skate.”
A relieved breath leaves my body as I gesture for her to go toward the rental desk. “Well, that I can help with.”
“There you go,” I say, holding onto one of her hands as I keep my other on the small of her back. “Nice and steady.”
She doesn’t respond, but that’s because she’s concentrating too hard on her balance and making sure she’s taking the tiniest strides possible. I can’t help but smile as I take her in. Her tongue is out the slightest bit in determination. She’s laser-focused on the ice. And I don’t think she’s breathing. She’s definitely not blinking.
It’s pretty adorable.
“I see you smirking,” she says through tight lips.
“No smirking,” I say, even as I feel the smirk turn into a full smile. “You’re doing great.”