AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Unlikely Pair

Page 65

by Chelle Sloan

God, I’m fucking this all up. “I mean, you are. And you’re the first one I thought of. And that might have to do with just seeing you recently. But it’s more than that. I trust you. And I think of you as a friend. Frankly, if I was going to do this harebrained idea with anyone, it’s only going to be you.”

“Wow,” she says, blinking a few times as she takes in my words. “I’m flattered. I think.”

I take a deep breath, because I could explain my justifications to her, but really, it all comes down to this. “I know I need to date eventually. But I’m not entirely ready, and…the people around me pushing me to do it…it’s getting to be overwhelming. I thought that…”

“That if you had a girlfriend, they’d lay off?”

I let out a breath. “Exactly.”

Silence comes over us again, but it’s not awkward like it was at the beginning. I don’t know what Sutton is thinking. I can’t read her. I’m just hoping now that she’s heard everything, she’s not about to change her mind.

“What else can I answer?” I say, suddenly needing to fill the silence. “What else do you want to know?”

She takes a second before she responds. “One thing. Well, a lot of things, but one thing now.”

“Anything.”

“Earlier, you said for me to remember a point about Rob. That he was upset about the auction. What does that have to do with me and whether or not I agree to this?”

“It’s probably silly, and maybe a little petty,” I admit. “But when he came into practice today, after he was done throwing his tantrum about not being in the auction, he was going on about how he couldn’t wait to go back to Vancouver for ‘one last round.’ He said it vaguely enough where some guys could think he was talking about hockey. But for those of us who’ve known Rob more than five minutes, we know it means he has a girl in Vancouver he’s going to see one last time before the season is over.”

Sutton rolls her eyes so far in the back of her head I can barely see her irises. “Why am I not surprised?”

“It pisses me off,” I say. “The man is fucking engaged and is still bragging about his cheating. While in the same breath asking if any of us are planning his bachelor party. So, as I was trying to justify my plan, and wondering how I could get you to say yes—because I honestly don’t know why you’d help me with this—part of me wondered if there’s part of you that would like to be petty with me and start dating me to piss him off. You know, just for shits and giggles?”

Sutton is a smiley person. In our short time of knowing each other, I’ve already learned three different ones she has for different occasions. But this one? The one that has a touch of evil in it? This is a new one. And I kind of like it. Actually, it might be my new favorite.

“I try not to be petty,” she begins. “I believe in second chances and silver linings and that we don’t always know everyone’s story.”

“But?”

“But when it comes to Rob—or as I’ve come to know him, my ex-in-law—being petty is the least I can do. He’s a horrible, horrible, person who doesn’t deserve nice things. Especially if he’s cheating on my sister, who also isn’t the best person and will never believe me if I try to tell her, but no one deserves that. Plus, I never truly had any sort of revenge when I caught him cheating on me. This could be kind of fun.”

“You caught him?”

“I did.”

“With…” I don’t want to finish that sentence because I have a feeling I know the answer.

“My sister. In the throws. Reverse cowgirl to be exact.”

I feel my jaw hit the table.

“It’s okay,” she says, leaning over and actually pushing it back into place. “I’m better off. My kid is going to be in therapy for a long time when he realizes he has a daddy-uncle, and that his father is a piece of shit. But I’ll be there to help him through that, too.”

“Yeah, once the guys found out about the daddy-uncle of it all, we decided that when we feel like pissing him off, we’ll just call him Duncle.”

She snortlaughs and nods her head. “I like that. I have many interesting nicknames for the screwed up situation my family and I are in,” she says. “But you’re right without realizing it. I do have a reason to do this, and it has everything to do with Rob. And my sister.”

I don’t know what she’s talking about, but before I can ask her, she shows me a text message on her phone.

Sis

Can you show me a picture of who you’re bringing before you confirm with him? If he’s going to be in wedding photos, Mom and I want to make sure he fits the vibe of the wedding. We wouldn’t want an ugly person in the pictures.

“Did she really just type those words?”

“She did,” Sutton says without typing back a response. “I have to go to this wedding whether I like it or not. I have to smile and pretend everything’s fine and it’s not weird that I’ve had sex with my brother-in-law.”