Page 102
Sometime in the middle of a story she’s telling me about some argument Beau and Shelby were having, I realize I haven’t panicked once. No guilt. No heavy breathing. No freaking out about holding her hand or how I looked at her. No overthinking how she felt against me when I was holding her. If anything, my thoughts were just those a man would have about a beautiful woman.
And maybe that should scare me more than anything.
Yet, somehow, it doesn’t.
“I purposely didn’t eat in the suite just for this.” She’s practically bouncing with excitement as we sit down at the restaurant.
“It’s after ten,” I say. “You really didn’t eat anything?”
“Some popcorn and I grazed on the veggie platter. But when you know you have a ribeye and a baked potato coming, you don’t ruin your appetite on hot dogs.”
“Oh no, there were hot dogs in the suite?”
Sutton laughs at my comment, knowing exactly what I’m referring to. “Yes. I never knew one man could be so opinionated on the variations of a hot dog?”
I shake my head. “Yeah, Theo has many opinions about them. Maybe because he’s a baseball player and it’s the game’s staple? And don’t get him started on whether or not they’re a sandwich. That’ll be your whole night.”
“It was. Well, just the first intermission,” she says with a giggle. “Luckily, I’m on his side, so I was safe from any lectures.”
“Oh, I meant to ask, how was Ellie? I wish I could’ve met her.”
“Well you still have your chance. She didn’t come.”
That takes me aback. “Really? No one texted me to let me know?”
Sutton shrugs. “They knew we were going out after dinner, so maybe they figured I’d tell you?”
Probably, but I’m still going to fire off a text to Beau and Maddox because I thought for sure this was the time Ellie would make her debut.
“Besides Theo's Ted Talk on hot dogs, did you have a good time?”
The smile on her face says it all. “It was amazing. Your friends are awesome. Shelby and Beau? They're a hoot and a half. I’d never met Maddox and he's just the nicest guy. And I know he was a little off tonight, but Theo and I had a blast. We did every chant and cheer. I don’t know how I still have a voice. Honestly? You might’ve heard me screaming after you got sent to the box in the second period. What was that ref thinking…”
I know Sutton is talking about the game, and I really am listening to her. But more than that, I'm watching every one of her features as she lights up talking to me about the game like I wasn't there. Her eyes are sparkling. Her eyebrows go up and down as she talks about an exciting moment we had where Finn had to use his entire body to block a goal. And her hands? They’re everywhere. It’s adorable.
She’s adorable.
Dammit…I shouldn’t be thinking that…
“Shit.”
That one word pulls me out of my daze. “What?”
“Rob and Angelina.”
I don’t care about being nonchalant as I turn over my shoulder so I can see the front of the restaurant. And there they are, in the selfish flesh.
“Are you okay?” I ask. “We haven’t put in our order yet. We can go somewhere else.”
Sutton shakes her head. “No. They were going to see us together sooner or later. Sooner is winning out. Plus, maybe this will confirm for my sister that I’m not lying about bringing you to the wedding.”
“She thought you were lying?” I ask. “I know you said that before, but I thought you were exaggerating.”
“Not in the least. When I told her you were my plus one, she laughed and told me to stop playing games. I insisted I wasn’t. Then she accused me of paying you to be my date.”
“Wait. I could be getting paid?”
“If you take payments in free haircuts, sure,” she teases. “After she accused me of being unable to let go of the spotlight for a day—because apparently I need a hockey player to try and one-up her—she accused us of being in a fake relationship.”