AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Witch is Dead

Page 44

by Geneva Monroe

I dipped my chin to her brow, using the palm on the back of her head to redirect her to my shoulder. This confession was hard enough without adding the weight of her gaze to it. There was an honesty in her eyes that was raw, and it stripped me to the bone.

After staring for several long moments at the heavy ceiling rafters and centuries-old stones, I continued, “My father didn’t trust her, but in a rare show of defiance, I refused to let him shoot her. So, he gave Cat to me, said that he always knew I’d never do better than another man’s trash—that at least this way he’d get a grandson who might one day live up to the Ciopriani legacy. To him, saving Caterina was just another in a long line of disappointments, and Cat, she went from being promised to one heir, to being in debt to another.”

I could feel the muscles of Thea’s neck flex as she swallowed. She was being uncharacteristically quiet.

“Despite the circumstances, over the next year, we grew closer than I’ve ever allowed myself to get to a person.”

“You loved her.” It wasn’t a question, more of an affirmation.

“I think, I thought that I loved her. I know now she never loved me. She was looking for something she could take as her own, and I was stupid enough to give it to her.” I sank my fingers into the hair at Thea’s nape, watching the strands grow bright red in the light streaming through the window. Seeing them match the sauce staining my fingers was oddly comforting. “When Enzo discovered that Cat had left him for the son of the man that had ruined his father, he gathered the old families, and they hired Eastin Witcher to even the scales.”

Thea involuntarily recoiled at the sound of that witch’s name, only held in place by the wrap of my arms. I understood the impulse. It was the same reaction that made my hand curl into a fist along her scarred spine.

“Eastin offered Caterina the autonomy she craved in exchange for me. She set Cat up in her territory, carving out a tiny kingdom where she didn’t have to be under anyone’s control ever again. I followed her blindly right into Eastin’s trap, and she never showed an ounce of remorse. Eastin placed the hammer in her hands. I think more than any of the physical pain she inflicted on me, what Eastin delighted in most was corrupting someone who looked so sweet.”

“When you say hammer?” Thea pushed against my chest, leaning up on her elbows to peer down at me.

I closed my eyes, unable to forget the way Cat’s gleamed with power as she dropped the mallet.

“Caterina broke my heart and my leg with a single swipe.”

Thea’s face twisted into one of abject horror, but now that I was telling it, I couldn’t stop.

“They took turns. Breaking each bone, one at a time. The louder I screamed, the harder they went. It took 37 surgeries to set my skeleton back into the semblance of a man. Several bones were shattered so completely that titanium implants are all that hold them together, a few of the joints had to be entirely replaced.” I tried to laugh it off but couldn’t bring myself to do more than huff. “I’m more metal than flesh.”

I flexed my hand, feeling the weight of the pins holding the bones in place. Thea’s eyes fell on the tattoo inked over my fingers. Her lips mouthed their message. Never Again. But I knew in my soul that those words were a lie because I’d follow this woman into the fires of hell.

“The day I went missing, Enzo sent my father a letter. He made sure that Salvatore Ciopriani understood that all of my suffering on the way to a very long death was by his own hand…maybe not directly, but by his action. My pain was the price demanded by the old families in retribution for my father’s betrayal.”

A tremor vibrated within Thea; it was slight, but I recognized the barely controlled rage. Now she knew why I didn’t trust the man who raised me.

“Over the months of my captivity, she’d send videos to my father. I know because she’d always make me say hello, even when she wired my jaw shut so I couldn’t scream.”

Thea’s hand sprang up to cover her reaction, but she was unable to hide the way her eyes sparkled with the tears building in them. I cupped her cheek. There was a macabre beauty to her shock.

“He assessed that I was an acceptable loss in exchange for the kingdom he’d created for himself.”

“Why can’t we kill him?” Thea pushed away a tear at the corner of her eye with the heel of her hand. Blood rushed to her cheeks, making her eyes look greener. I traced the lines of her face, wishing that I could remove the hardness in them. I didn’t deserve her rage.

I blew out a hard breath. “I’ve been asking myself that question since we arrived.” Despite all he’d done to me over the years, I’d never truly considered patricide until I’d seen how he’d looked at Thea.

“Danny and Crowe eventually figured out a way to free me. When I was well enough to stand before my father, I told him I was out. We were out. On that day, I vowed that I would never again trust or love another.” I tipped her chin up, my lips ghosting over hers. “Until you.”

The truth of my statement grew, and with it, I pulled her into me, kissing her like she was the beginning and end of everything. A new person formed beneath her with each press of our lips until, more than any metal pin, it felt like the only thing holding me together was her.

Thea pulled away with a long exhale. Her hands coasted down my arms, slowing along each curve like she was memorizing the map of scars. Drawing one finger through the sauce streaking my chest, she drew a heart over where the organ beneath thumped happily sated. The tingling sensation of her fingers swelled, spreading out from the center and enveloping me in a blanket of warmth.

She swiped her hand through the tomato massacre on the ground, wiggling her fingers with a tiny hello. Salsa gleamed on their surface. It made my heart skip with a weird pang of possession. Her lower lip pinned mischievously between her teeth, Thea slapped her handprint directly over the drawn heart.

“Just so there’s no confusion, this is me officially calling dibs. You’re mine, Angel.”

If it wasn’t for the slow rhythm beating in my chest, I’d have thought I was having a heart attack. I took her hand, placing a kiss in the center of her palm. She blinked, a crooked smile breaking across her face and setting her features alight. A riot of emotion all quieted with that smile, focusing themselves into one devastating thought. I loved this girl.

“What about the others?”

Thea looked down, tracing tiny patterns in the paste coating the ground. “They’re mine too. You’re all mine.” When her eyes lifted again, I knew I could never deny her. She could ask for the entire world right now, and I’d be figuring out how to gift-wrap it. “I can’t explain it. But I think being loaded on that truck might be the best thing that ever happened to me.”

Panic and worry, unlike any I’d known, caught back up to me. My father’s warnings were still too fresh in my mind, eclipsed only by images of her beautiful face flashing on the screen with a price attached. Thea was a prize that so many wanted. We were in The Villa, under the same roof as the most cutthroat and opportunistic members in Oz’s underworld. The only thing keeping her safe was the thin promise of a corrupt old man. How long could that really last? Thea was worth more than most men saw in a lifetime, and I’d brought her straight into the viper’s den…and then stopped to fuck her on the kitchen floor.