AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend

Page 41

by Vivy Skys

"Iris, I know it is messed up."

"It is incredibly messed up," I choke out, tears coming fast enough that I'm furious with my own body for betraying me this quickly. "You swore to me when we were kids. You knew how scared I was that I would lose you to him. He's my brother. If you two destroy each other, I lose both of you, and I am already losing Dad one day at a time."

"You will not lose me," Sienna replies, shaking her head. "You will not lose him either, because nothing about this changes how much we love you."

"Do not use the word love if you are trying to calm me down." I counter.

"I am using it because it's true. I love him, Iris." She pleads.

"Swear to me this is not nostalgia and unfinished business."

"It's not," she answers immediately.

"Swear it on something that matters."

Sienna lifts her chin, steady now. "I swear on my parents, on you and me, and on my voice." Her voice is the one thing she has never once treated lightly in her entire life. If she's willing to swear on it, she's handing me the truest thing she owns.

I press both hands over my face and groan, the fight going out of me all at once. When I drop my hands, I point one finger at her. "I knew something was wrong with you two in high school. You both got weird whenever I mentioned him."

Sienna bites her lip. "He kissed me the night of your seventeenth birthday. In the oak tree. After Lionel."

It all clicks into place.

"That is why you were so calm about Lionel," I breathe. "You told me first kisses didn't count when they were bad because my brother had kissed you right after it."

"In my defense, Lionel was terrible."

"You do not get a defense. You stole emotional wisdom from my brother and used it on me."

"I repurposed it with love," Sienna counters, mouth twitching.

"I am going to need you to put on an apron before I decide whether I'm still mad enough to throw flour at you," I tell her, tossing one across the counter.

She catches it, laughing. "Are we baking or reconciling?"

"Both. I am behind because I stress-baked all morning, and you are going to help me roll these out while you tell me everything you hid from me."

Sienna ties the apron and reaches for the rolling pin. "Where do you want me to start?"

"At the oak tree. Continue through the beach, Boston, the two years of silence, the lupine field, and why you are wearing a ring that looks like my brother bought it with his entire soul."

Her hand stills over the rolling pin, just for a second, but I catch it, and I catch the ring itself properly for the first time, a pearl framed by little blue stones, soft and old-fashioned and so specifically Grayson that my chest aches on his behalf.

"Oh," I whisper, reaching for her hand before I ask permission to.

She lets me take it. My brother kept a flower field folded up somewhere in his heart for this exact woman longer than I ever knew to look for it, loving her quietly under everyone's nose while I stood right there missing it.

"It's like we are already sisters," I murmur, blinking hard.

"We’ve always been sisters."

"I am still mad," I warn, pointing at the dough between us.

"You are allowed," she answers, pressing the rolling pin into it.

We bake. She tells me enough for the timeline to fill in, the oak tree, the beach, The Whaler, Boston, Nicki, the contract pressure, the fifty million dollars, the lawyer, the lupine field, the ring, and with every confession my anger changes shape without fully disappearing, stretching to make room for grief and tenderness and the humbling knowledge that people I love were hurting within arm's reach of me the whole time.

After a while, I clear my throat.