Page 74
Oh no, no, no, no, no.
My face flames red as all eyes turn our way, and I watch as Eli pivots, his eyebrows raised.
“Get your butt over here, Eli,” Floyd hollers, waving his hand with urgency.
Eli glances around, sighs heavy and comes our way, because when Floyd commands you to come, you come.
I watch him cross the green with his jaw set and wariness in every line of his beautiful face. I should stop this… I know it’s going to be embarrassing, but I’m also a bit curious as to what’s about to happen. Eli and I haven’t been able to say any of the right words together, so maybe Floyd will say them for us.
“Floyd,” Eli says evenly, cutting me a quick glance. “What do you need?”
“You’re just gonna let her leave?”
Eli’s ears go flame red and he shoots me a helpless look before squaring his shoulders toward Floyd. “That’s her business, buddy. And mine. Not the whole square’s.”
“See, that’s where you’re wrong,” Morri says pleasantly, “because you two have been conducting this entire romance in the most public forum in the American South. So it is, in fact, all of our business now. We’re invested. We have feelings too, you know.”
“There’s no romance.” Eli’s voice is tight. He doesn’t look at me. “We’re friends. We had a nice… it was casual. That’s all.” He finally brings his gaze to mine. “Tell ’em, Reese.”
And for some reason, that lands like a slap to the face, because I’ve been standing here for an hour drowning and he just said it was casual to the whole town without a hiccup in his words.
And I just snap.
“Right,” I hear myself say, too bright, too sharp. “Casual. Just two people passing the time. He said it, so it must be true. Eli Hart said it, and Eli Hart never says a word more than he has to, so there you go.”
Eli’s eyes narrow on me. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
I lift a shoulder. “It doesn’t mean anything other than it’s casual, remember?” I’m aware the crowd has gone quiet and thick around us and I can’t stop. “You’re the one who just announced it to the town.”
“You agreed to casual, Reese! First week! You said temporary—you said you don’t stay in places for too long.”
“Because that’s what you wanted!” It rips out of me and in my peripheral vision, I see people moving in closer to listen. “You never once said different! And you never once said stay!”
“Because you were leaving,” he growls, stepping in close to me. “And what was I supposed to do, ask you to give up your entire life?”
“You could’ve asked me something,” I retort, as Mary-Margaret and Sissy move in slow and close, their shoulders touching mine. “You could’ve told me one true thing! You know what you did instead?” And here it comes, the splinter, the thing I tucked away over scorched chicken last night. “I told you what Crystal said… that you can’t commit, that you’ll never give anybody the real thing… and you didn’t deny it, Eli. I handed you the chance, and you just waved it off and reached for the salt!”
“I needed the salt to make it past the burnt ends of your chicken,” he snaps. I blink at him in surprise, shocked he’d malign my cooking to the entire world. But before I can hurl an insult back, he takes a deep breath and sighs. “Wait a minute… you think I was agreeing with Crystal?”
“What was I supposed to think?”
“That I don’t waste breath on that woman!” he roars and the whole square goes electric with it. “That I’ve been over her for ten years and I couldn’t care less what she says! I didn’t deny it because it wasn’t worth dignifying, not because it was true. God, Reese, it’s the opposite of true.”
“Then SAY the opposite!” I demand, poking him in the chest for good measure.
“Say it,” Sissy agrees.
“That’s right,” Mary-Margaret adds on.
“FINE!” He throws his hands up and spins in a circle, taking in the fact that we’re now surrounded by everyone listening in. All the Mancinkus tribe, Pap, Morri, Floyd and Muriel and dozens of other faces I don’t even know.
Eli scrubs a hand through his hair in frustration and throws both arms out helplessly. “The opposite is… the truth is… I’d commit to you in a heartbeat. The opposite is I’ve wanted to ask you to stay since you threw that rake in a tree and I’ve been swallowing it every single day because I didn’t think I had the right! Is that TRUE enough for you?!”
The square’s gone absolutely silent except for the hog fat hissing on Floyd’s cooker.
I can’t breathe. “You… what?”
“I don’t want you to go.” He says it furious, helpless, at full volume, in front of God and the entire town of Whynot. “There. That’s the thing I’ve been not-saying. I’ve been standing here all night watching this party like a funeral, letting you go because that’s the noble thing, because your whole life is out there and mine’s here. I couldn’t figure out how to want you to stay without asking you to be small.”