Page 29
As mad as I am about my mother hiding this part of her life from me—and yes, I’m mad—an overwhelming wave of empathy and love for her wells up inside me. What a terrible thing to have to go through by yourself. At least when my mom died, both Theo and I took care of her. We did it as a team and it was so comforting having him there.
Catherine looks at me steadily and I realize I’m crying. I didn’t decide to. It’s just running down my face and Catherine slides a paper napkin across the table without comment.
A grandfather who ran off. A grandmother named Eleanor who died slow and brave. A teenager who held the whole thing together by herself and then walked away from all of it.
And for some unknown reason, she built a brand-new person in Ohio and never once, not once, let me know any of this existed.
“My life started when I met your dad,” she’d always said.
I used to think that was romance, but I’m thinking it was avoidance.
“What was she like?” I blurt out, dabbing at my eyes. “My mom.”
“Now, I have to be honest, I didn’t know her close.” Catherine glances at my biscuits and I feel guilty for ignoring her hard work. My stomach is doing flops, but I load up my fork and take a bite, and all of a sudden, I’m starving again. It’s so good.
I eat while Catherine talks. “She was three years younger than me, and at that age that’s a canyon. Different circles, you understand. I was off at college about the time she was in high school, but Whynot’s small, and a girl like that, you noticed her.” She smiles, remembering. “She was sweet. Genuinely so. Outgoing as the day’s long… never met a stranger, that one. And pretty as a picture, just like you, but it wasn’t the pretty people remembered.” Catherine taps the table. “It was the voice.”
“The voice?” I croak out, my fork poised above the biscuits.
“Lord, that girl could sing.” Catherine’s whole face lights up. “Sing like an angel come down. They’d have her do the hymns at church and you’d get chills, swear before God. That’s how she won the Miss Whynot pageant, you know. Half those girls did baton or recited a monologue, and Melissa Rhodes just stood up there and sang a song that she wrote herself.” She chuckles. “Wasn’t even really a competition.”
She keeps talking, but I’ve stopped hearing her, because the floor has gone out from under me again.
My mother could sing?
No.
No, she couldn’t. She sang happy birthday off-key and turned the radio down when she had to concentrate. I never heard her singing along with music. She was never moved by it.
I’m sure of it.
And now I’m being told my mother sang like an angel and won a crown doing it.
“Reese?” Catherine’s watching me. “You’ve gone white, hon.”
“She never sang.” My voice comes out strange. “In my whole life, I never heard her sing once.” I press the napkin to my mouth. “Why would somebody do that? Why would you give up… why would you hide a thing like that from your own kid?”
Catherine doesn’t have an answer. She just reaches across and covers my hand with hers, warm and dry and motherly.
It’s a while before I can ask the next thing. “Is there anything else? Anything you remember? Even small? Even… weird?”
Something shifts in her face. A hesitation. She glances toward the window, like she’s deciding whether to hand it to me.
“There was the fire,” she finally says, bringing her gaze back to me.
The hair goes up on my arms. “Fire?”
“Now, I want to be straight with you, because I won’t pass off gossip as gospel in my own kitchen.” She holds up a hand. “I was away at school when it happened, so everything I know is secondhand and years stale. But the very night your mama was crowned, the Founder’s Day stage was set on fire and burned to the ground. Big to-do. Nobody hurt, thank the Lord, but it was the talk of the town for years.”
“A fire,” I repeat.
She nods solemnly. “Here’s the part I can’t speak to, so take it for what it’s worth.” Catherine’s mouth pinches, careful. “There was talk, the way a small town does because everybody’s got to have a reason, a culprit, somebody to blame. And the story that got around, the one I heard, was that the runner-up did it. The girl who came in second to your mama.” She shakes her head. “Sore loser was the theory. Folks said she was so et up jealous over losing that crown she set the stage afire out of spite. Now whether there was a lick of truth to it, I couldn’t tell you. People love an ugly story more than a true one, in my experience, and that one had everything. It practically wrote itself.”
I think of the caption. The grainy photocopy folded in my bag.
“The runner-up,” I say slowly. “Bonnie Tutwiler.”
Catherine nods. “Yeah… Bonnie. People thought she did it, but I didn’t buy it.”