AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Never Kiss a Cowboy

Page 20

by Penelope Ryan

“Scottie,” Harrison says after a long pause, and the weight of his tone has me turning my head to look at him. He’s not looking at me, gaze still fixed to the sky above. But I can see his expression. The way his eyebrows are creased like he’s in physical pain, grimacing like something’s wrong. “I lied earlier.”

Now it’s my turn to frown.

“When I said I only liked your company,” he goes on. “I like you. That’s the end of the sentence. And I think you know what it means.”

I stare at him for a long moment, not knowing what to say. I swallow, turn back to stare at the stars. It seems easier to talk to them—it’s probably why Harrison is doing it.

“I just had to tell you,” he says quietly. “It’s eating me up inside. And I know you don’t feel the same way, and I’ll be respectful and everything, but I just needed you to know—”

“That’s not true,” I interrupt.

He stops, pauses. Then, “What’s not true?” I can hear the hope in his voice. Timid, fearful, but still hopeful.

I take a deep breath, stare at the stars. “I like you too.” It’s a whisper, barely there. And he must hear the fear in my voice, because he turns to me.

“Why does that sound like a ‘no’ then?” he asks quietly. Not angry, just curious.

The silence stretches between us as I search for something to say. Some kind of answer that makes sense. That is fair. But none of this has been fair. Not since the moment—

“I wasn’t expecting you,” I settle on. “I thought I’d have time.”

“Time for what?”

“To be less broken before someone came along.”

Harrison is quiet, and I can tell he’s trying not to pry while also trying to understand. I close my eyes, and last summer flashes through my mind. Matt was a bull rider I’d overlapped with on a handful of rodeos at the end of the season. He’d flirted with me, and despite the lack of initial spark, he’d worn me down and gotten me to go out with him. I knew he got around, so I wasn’t immensely interested, but I thought, Why not? Live a little.

“There was a guy I dated last year,” I tell him. “And things went … south.”

I remember him being a bit drunk and taking me back to his car. I’d offered to drive, but he wanted to fool around. We kissed, and when it got too heavy, I’d reiterated my offer to drive. What I remember most about that night is that I said no. I remember the word coming out of my mouth. I remember the excuses I’d made.

I don’t do this until I’m in a relationship.

I don’t feel well.

It’s getting late.

You look tired.

No.

“I can’t even say the word out loud.” The telltale pressure in the back of my throat is there, along with the tears welling in my eyes. Because I can’t escape them when I think about this, much less talk about it. I haven’t talked about it with anyone other than a therapist I’d seen last fall.

And when Matt finally heard me, finally understood what I was turning down, he’d leaned back with a look in his eyes that said more than any words ever could. Irritation. Anger. Fury.

And so I froze.

I didn’t push him away. I didn’t fight him off. I didn’t scream, I didn’t struggle.

But I did say no.

It’s what I tell myself over and over again. On the days that I doubt what happened to me was even real. “I said no,” I tell Harrison, “and he kept going.”

Because it really is that simple.

Harrison is so still beside me that I’m afraid to even look at him. I brace myself for what he might say. That I made this all up. That I’m exaggerating. That there’s no reason for this to impact me now.

Instead, I feel the warmth of his fingers softly intertwining with mine at our sides, and it’s so pure of a gesture—so sweet—I almost let out a sob.