Page 86
"I'm not scared of you," I say. "I checked."
He eyes me for a second. "So what do you want?"
"Proof."
"You said you believed me."
"I did. I do. That isn't the same as you being right."
He crosses to the bench along the far wall.
I've been trying not to look at that bench. There’s things laid out on it on a folded towel, arranged the way a dentist arranges tools, and I won't say what they are because I've decided not to look at them long enough to know.
What he picks up off the end of it is a binder.
A black three ring binder, the kind they sell in packs of four at any drugstore in the city, full enough that the rings don't quite shut.
"Here." He holds it out, then pulls it back a little. "You're going to be angry with me after."
"I'm already angry with you."
"Yeah." He puts it in my hands. "Fair."
It's organized. That's the part I wasn't ready for. It has tabs. It has numbered dividers with names on them in his real handwriting.
I sit down on the bottom stair with it open on my knees because this will take a while.
"Tab one," I say.
"Roach."
"There's a photograph of a doorframe in here."
"Yeah."
"And then there's a photograph of the same doorframe with a tape measure held up against it."
"Five nine." He says it like he's reading me a price. "That's where her head went."
"You drove there?"
"I drove there."
"You broke into a house and measured a dent?"
"Yeah."
I turn the page. A civil complaint with a case number on it. A screenshot of a post from a woman I've never heard of, four days after the complaint, forty comments under it.
Tab two is a hospital discharge summary with the name blacked out and the date left in.
Tab six ran a group home in Suffolk County for nine years, and four people wrote letters about what happened to them while they were in it.
I stop reading halfway down the page.
Then I hit a divider with EDDIE on it and I stop moving altogether. Because I know Eddie. Okay, I don't know Eddie. I know a woman who kept nine years of Sunday phone calls in her head and her son's phone records in a shoebox.
I open it.