Page 65
He taps the screen, plunging the room into darkness.
My breath hitches as he reaches around me and slides my phone into my back pocket.
“Don’t want to waste the battery.”
I inhale and nod, even though he can’t see me. “Smart.”
“I like the ladybug floor cloth,” he whispers.
My heart squeezes, because I know he’s trying to be nice, but it’s not his kind of thing. Neither is the hot sauce. Nate likes one brand of hot sauce, and he has zero desire to try anything new.
“I got you a present, too. It’s, uh, in my truck. I didn’t want to bring it in if you weren’t interested—”
I cut him off, kissing him. I don’t know why. We don’t have time for this. The lights will probably come on any minute, and the Stuff Room isn’t the place for anything more than a kiss.
Also, he’s not kissing me back the way he did the other two times.
“Cass.” He cups my face as he pulls his mouth away. “No.”
Emotion clogs my throat and I nod. No, of course not.
“It’s not that I don’t want to, sweetheart, but we can’t do that instead of talking.” He presses his forehead against mine. “Do you not want a Christmas present from me?”
“I don’t have one for you.”
“Maybe not one you intended to be for me, but you did give me something very important tonight.”
I shake my head. “Please don’t pretend that you like them.”
“It’s not pretending. I see them differently now. That ladybug will live in a place of pride on my kitchen floor. I can’t wait to try that hot sauce.”
“You don’t like new things.”
“Because I like things that I like. I’m a creature of comfort and routine. Or I was, until I blew up my life and lost my wife. Now I hate my routine and I haven’t been comfortable for a year. It’s past time I tried a new hot sauce. But more importantly, you gave me things that you made. And—”
“What are you doing?”
“What do you mean?”
“Why are you saying these things now? Tonight? A year after you told me that I was too much, then said nothing for an entire year, and tonight you bring a date who everyone in this house would describe as too much on every level—”
“I’m not dating Shaye. Have not, will not ever.”
“Then why is she here?”
“Because you assumed she was my date and I let that happen! That’s my greatest failing. I just let shit happen while I stand there like a stunned ox. Why am I saying this now? Because I waited too long. That’s the Nate McPherson story, over and over again. I should never have said that you’re too much. You could never be too much for me. You are so much, and I sometimes don’t know how to handle that—but that’s on me. That’s never a failing on your part. And I hope that Campbell, or Theo, or whoever you date next knows exactly what to do with you because you deserve to be treated like a queen. Seeing you flirt with them tonight…”
“So this is jealousy?” I think about our first kiss, interrupted by Ben. Our second kiss, which escalated even further—sparked by me telling him I had a date. “Possessive jealousy is not a good reason to hold on to me, Nate!”
The door pushes open behind him, a flashlight illuminating us for a brief second before Rory drops her hand. “Sorry, Mom says the candles are in here?”
“Yeah.” Nate puts his hands on my hips and moves me bodily out of the way so he can pull a box out from under the desk.
“How do you know where they—You knew they were there and let me look on the shelf?” I huff a frustrated breath and push past him, then past Rory.
Nate follows. “Cass, we’re not done.”
“Now is not the time,” I hiss in the middle of the hallway.