AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 9

by Becca Fall

I opened the PinnacleHoliday email.

The sign-up link led to a clean interface. It included a toggle for employees to opt into the pen pal program and a message explaining that matches would be randomized and that participants would remain anonymous until the reveal at the holiday party, identified only by auto-generated usernames.

Honestly, this was way more interesting than the regular Secret Santa, where you bought a gift for someone whose desk you could see from your own and everyone stood around the conference room table performing gratitude.

Sorry, Cassie—I was a hater on the Secret Santa front.

I typed in a username of random letters and numbers: P0X547TY.

The screen returned a confirmation: You’re in! Your match will be revealed on December 3. Get ready for some holiday magic!

Across the floor, Cassie laughed at something on her screen and my stomach jolted at the sound. She had pulled her second earbud out and was typing something fast, still smiling at whatever it was.

I wasn’t sure if the strange feeling in my stomach was from the ridiculous crush I had on her or from eating two cookies earlier.

The notification came two days later while I was on the subway, standing in the section between cars where the signal cut in and out.

Your PinnacleHoliday match is: SmilingsMyFavorite! Send your first message to get the holiday magic started. Remember to keep it anonymous!

SmilingsMyFavorite.

Where had I heard that before?

It clicked immediately.

Cassie, standing outside Conference Room B after a disastrous budget meeting, balancing a paper cup of coffee in one hand while explaining that Elf was the greatest Christmas movie ever made.

“Smiling’s my favorite,” she’d quoted in an overly cheerful voice, completely at odds with the death glare she’d sent me ten seconds earlier for interrupting her presentation.

When I’d informed her that a grown woman shouldn’t be taking life advice from an elf, she’d launched into a passionate defense of the movie.

The train rattled through dark tunnel walls. Around me, people swayed in practiced silence, eyes down, all of us pretending we were alone in a shared space.

The correct move was obvious.

Send an anonymous message. Participate normally. Exchange polite, low-effort holiday correspondence for a month. Buy a reasonable gift that could be explained as obligation rather than intent. Attend the party. Pack up my desk and leave the office for good.

The reveal would be awkward for a few minutes, but I’d endure it. The twenty-second was my last day of work, so it wasn’t like I’d ever see her again.

The thought of that made me feel uneasy.

I also hadn’t found the right opportunity to tell her I was leaving. Would she even care that there wouldn’t be any more passing each other in the break room? Would she miss our spontaneous arguments in the hall?

Would she miss me?

I took a deep breath and counted the people in this part of the train. Nineteen.

The train slowed into my stop. I stepped off with the rest of the platform and moved toward the escalator.

Freddie Martinez had been my closest friend since freshman year of college. We had lived on the same floor and figured out within a day that neither of us had the energy for forced small talk, but both of us were perfectly willing to spend three hours doing something physically exhausting without complaining.

He was also a fantastic boxer and proved that fact by kicking my ass on a regular basis.

We’d been coming to this place on West 29th for two years. It was a real gym, not a boutique one, which meant the lighting was harsh, the mirrors were slightly warped at the edges, and the equipment had a worn look from being used properly for a long time.

There were no neon signs, no pop playlists, and most importantly, no one setting up a phone to record themselves doing a single set of something they weren’t going to finish.

Freddie fit into the space well. He had a shaved head, a thin scar along his left eyebrow that I had never asked about, and a geometric-shaped tattoo that wrapped around his right forearm.