AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 56

by Becca Fall

Alex reached down to cup my cheek, thumb brushing away a stray tear I hadn’t even realized I’d shed.

“You okay?” he asked, voice tender, and I managed a nod, leaning into his touch, my body vibrating with aftershocks and the lingering glow of intimacy.

After toweling down, I settled into his lap once again, resting my head on his shoulder, letting my eyes drift closed while his fingers traced lazy patterns on my back.

The tree lights painted gold across his skin, and I was content to watch them—and him—for a long while.

12

ALEX

Christmas Day arrived.

I had spent the previous three Christmases in New York in varying states of fine—one with Freddie and his family in Queens, one alone in the apartment with good takeout and a book I had been meaning to read, and one on the phone with my parents in California, watching the same movie simultaneously two time zones apart.

This one was different.

Cassie was still asleep beside me, facing the window, her hair spread across the pillow. I woke up before she did, to no surprise. I was an early riser by disposition and Cassie, I was learning, was an early riser by intention.

She got up at five fifteen on December first to bake cookies, but left to her own devices, she would sleep in and feel no guilt about it whatsoever.

I got up carefully and went to the kitchen, standing at the window with my coffee.

It had snowed overnight, just enough to sit on the parked cars and the window ledges. A white Christmas. Cassie would love it.

Behind me, I heard someone moving in the bedroom, followed by footsteps. Cassie appeared in the kitchen doorway in my gray crewneck. The sleeves covered part of her hands, the neckline slipped slightly off one shoulder, and her hair was still in that unstructured, sleep-heavy state that made it clear she hadn’t made any attempt to manage it.

I lifted an arm around her shoulders, pulling her closer to me. “Good morning.”

“Good morning.” She buried her nose in my shoulder. “I’m so happy I didn’t sleepwalk.”

“You sleepwalk?”

“On occasion. I’m trying to teach myself how to sleep bake.”

I held out the second mug of coffee I had already poured, complete with enough almond milk to turn the brew into a light color. “I look forward to witnessing it.”

She took it with both hands. “You know how I take my coffee.”

“Mmhm. You’re the only person in the office who puts almond milk in it, yet somehow the office manager includes it in every grocery delivery.”

“Because she likes me.” Cassie took a sip. “And technically, it’s your old office now since—Wait.”

She stepped past me to the window and put one hand flat on the glass, looking down at the white street below.

“Alex,” she said. “It snowed on Christmas.”

One of the things I liked most about Cassie was that she never concealed the things that made her happy. She embraced them fully and didn’t let anyone else’s opinions sway her.

She turned back, a mix of gratitude and delight on her face.

Her eyes were so bright. She was a person who had spent every Christmas of her adult life making the season real for the people around her, who had woken up every December first like it was the best day, who had built an entire month of small exhibits for a stranger who turned out not to be a stranger at all.

I wanted to be the one to make every future Christmas special for her, too.

“Merry Christmas, Cassie,” I said.

She crossed the kitchen and kissed me, still holding her coffee, the warmth of the mug lingering lightly between us.