AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 36

by Becca Fall

I opened the first.

Immediately it looked too busy. There were multiple elements competing for attention, like I had been trying to prove something instead of say something.

The second was cleaner but missing something.

The third…

I had made that one at one in the morning, slightly delirious, sitting on this exact chair with flour still on my hands and no intention of showing it to anyone. A small, illustrated rolling pin worked into the lettering of Cassie’s Crumbs.

Perfect.

Tomorrow I had my conversation with the landlord to discuss the details of the building. Pretty sure I would be put on the spot to make a decision about moving forward.

Pretty sure I would say yes.

The realization made my hands shake. Then I reached for my tea, took a sip, and made a face when I realized it had gone completely cold.

I told Priya on Saturday afternoon over takeout, which was how most important life updates in our apartment were delivered—standing barefoot in the kitchen, the radiator hissing unevenly in the corner, the counter cluttered with mugs and a fruit bowl that neither of us had restocked in days.

“I had a call with the landlord this morning,” I said, trying for casual but landing somewhere in the vicinity of freaking the fuck out.

Priya didn’t respond right away. She was leaning against the counter with a carton of noodles in one hand and chopsticks in the other, mid-bite, and she slowly lowered both like she needed her full attention available for whatever I was about to say next.

“How did it go?” she asked.

“We talked for thirty minutes.” I paused, the words catching up to the part of my brain that was still processing. “He said my concept makes sense for the neighborhood.”

Priya straightened, setting her takeout container down with more care than necessary.

“Wow.” She pushed off the counter and took a step closer to me. “This could be the right fit, then?”

“Yeah, I think so,” I said and could hear something in my own voice shift as I said it again, something steadier this time. “He’s sending over a contract later this week.”

Priya’s eyes widened slightly. It was the calibrated look most people got when something tipped from hypothetical into real.

“A contract,” she echoed.

“Just a draft,” I said quickly.

“Wow,” she said again, and there was warmth in it, but also something firmer, like she was anchoring the moment so I couldn’t float away from it. “This is actually happening.”

I looked down at my coffee, watching the faint swirl of cream that had long since settled into nothing.

“It’s just a contract,” I said, because part of me still wanted to minimize it into something manageable. “It doesn’t commit me to anything. I can look at it, ask questions, decide it’s not the right time⁠—”

“You can,” she agreed easily. “But you won’t.”

I smiled softly. “Yeah. I won’t.”

“What made you do it?” she asked after a moment. “You’ve been circling this idea forever.”

I turned my mug slowly in my hands, my thumb catching on the small chip along the rim that I always noticed and never fixed, buying myself a second to figure out how to explain something that felt both obvious and strange when I tried to put it into words.

“My anonymous pen pal, actually,” I said.

Priya’s brows lifted. “Really?”

“In a weird way, he kind of gets it. He’s not overly sentimental about things, which I think helped. He just—” I paused, searching for the right phrasing. “He made it sound like the decision wasn’t about being fearless. Just about being willing to try.”