AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 24

by Becca Fall

Okay. Right in front of everyone, though?

Very slowly, the sound came back in muffled voices and stifled laughs.

I pushed myself up onto my elbows.

Cassie was beside me, half sitting, half kneeling in the wreckage, her eyes wide as she took in the scene.

“Oh my God,” she said, each word carefully spaced, like she was still catching up to what had just happened. “We just ruined the cookie decorating contest.”

“That seems accurate,” I said.

Around us, the entire floor had stopped. Jaws dropped across the room, mixing with a few laughs.

Cassie closed her eyes for a second, inhaled slowly, then exhaled as though she’d reached the end of an argument with herself.

When she opened them again, she was composed.

“Alex and I are very sorry,” she said, projecting just enough for the room to hear. “This was clearly an accident, but we understand that we have disrupted the integrity of the competition.”

The integrity of the competition?

I wisely kept my mouth shut.

“I’ll replace the cookies,” she added weakly. “I make a mean sugar cookie.”

A few whoops echoed from the back of the room, and the tension finally loosened. People drifted away, bending to gather broken trays and scattered decorations.

“Shouldn’t you say naughty sugar cookie?” I pushed to my feet and held out my hand.

Cassie’s brows knitted together as she slipped her hand into mine. “What?”

I tugged her up, and she landed closer than either of us seemed prepared for. Close enough that the scent of cinnamon wrapped around me. I could count the gold flecks in her brown eyes.

“Because of the naughty and nice list,” I said, my voice coming out lower than intended. “Your cookies aren’t mean. They’re naughty.”

Cassie laughed.

“I never would’ve expected a Christmas pun from you,” she said, still smiling. “That might be the best thing I’ve heard all day.”

I smiled back before I could stop myself.

Crazy, considering her laugh had just become the best thing I’d heard all day.

That evening, back at my apartment, I found a message waiting in the app.

SmilingsMyFavorite

Did you hear about the cookie fiasco today?

I leaned back into the couch, one arm slung over the back like that might somehow distance me from the fact that I had been not just a witness, but a central cause. Despite my best efforts, frosting still coated my button-up.

So, yes, I more than heard about the fiasco. I had physically participated in its destruction. Cassie had too.

P0X547TY

I did. Sounds super awkward.

SmilingsMyFavorite