AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Holiday Pen Pal Twist

Page 16

by Becca Fall

“Oh, dear.”

I settled into the armchair, pulling my knees up and balancing the plate carefully.

“He told me that he’s not sure Christmas magic is there for him. Because his family struggled financially growing up, he felt weird about the holiday and the absence of gift giving. I want to give him some Christmas magic this year. I’m going to convert him into a Christmas person.”

“Cassie.” Priya tucked one leg more firmly under her. “I say this with love, but every year, you try to convert someone into a Christmas person. And every year, you fail.”

“…but this time I might succeed.”

Priya laughed. “I wish I had your resilience.”

You’re resilient, Cassie.

Alex’s voice floated in my head. His voice had a warmth to it, one that made me wonder how he sounded in the morning after he woke up. Would it have stayed that soft if we had scooted an inch closer in the closet? If I had brought my hand toward his⁠—

Whoa. Where did that thought come from?

I knocked my head against the chair once to get Alex’s voice out. The fact that this didn’t faze Priya probably said a lot about me.

I stabbed a noodle with my fork and took a bite, chewing thoughtfully as I stared at the TV without seeing it. There was something different about my pen pal.

Usually, when I tried to convert someone, it was obvious from the beginning how it would go. They would resist. I would insist. There would be baked goods involved, maybe a playlist, and an argument about the importance of leaning into something good in a world that wasn’t always that.

This didn’t feel predictable. P0X547TY wasn’t shutting me down completely, though he pushed back deliberately.

I took another bite and scrolled through my phone with my free hand, half looking at emails, half still replaying the conversation in my head. An anonymous pen pal shouldn’t take up this much space in my head.

I clicked into my inbox and froze.

Re: Retail Space on West 82nd – Availability Update

My fork lowered slowly onto the plate.

“Priya,” I said, not looking away from my phone. “Can you come here for a second?”

She muted the TV entirely this time. “What happened?”

“I don’t know yet,” I murmured.

I tapped the email.

It expanded on the screen, and I was hit with a sudden gust of awareness that this had the potential to rearrange my life.

Hi Cassie,

I wanted to reach out with an update regarding the retail space on West 82nd that you toured last month. The current tenant has decided to terminate their lease early, which means the space will now be available as of February 1. Given your previous interest, I wanted to check in to see if you would like to move forward.

Best,

Leon Rosen

“They moved it up,” I said, my voice coming out flatter than I expected.

Priya stood and crossed the room, popcorn abandoned on the couch. “Moved what up?”

“The bakery space.” I handed her my phone. “It’s available February first.”

She read it quickly, her hazel eyes moving in sharp lines.