Page 1
1
CASSIE
December first, in my completely unbiased opinion, was the greatest day of the year.
Better than my birthday, which always fell in August and therefore lacked the critical element of snowfall. Better than New Year’s, which was just December’s sad, hungover sequel when everyone pretended they were going to start journaling and drinking green juice.
This next statement might make people think I’m crazy, but I believed December first was even better than Christmas itself.
Why, you ask?
Because December first was the beginning of the Christmas season.
It was the moment the glorious month opened like an advent calendar, and everything that came out of it was either chocolate, peppermint, or joy.
Today, my alarm went off at five fifteen, but I was already awake.
Every year, the same thing happened: I’d spend the last week of November in a state of low-grade anticipation, and then the night before, no matter how deliberately I’d try to tire myself out with chamomile tea and one and a half episodes of Dateline (most people say it makes them too scared to sleep, but it knocks me right out), I would lie in bed with my eyes open, thinking about ornaments.
By five thirty, I had my Mariah-Carey-has-officially-defrosted playlist going. You know the one.
“All I Want for Christmas Is You” hit the first chorus right as I tied my hair into a messy bun that would, over the next hour, accumulate flour like it was part of the recipe.
I had the butter out to soften before I even turned the kitchen light on. The faint blue glow of early morning filtered through the window, a shade of yellowy orange that made everything feel a little magical. Nothing could bring me down—
“You’re unwell,” Priya said from the hallway.
I turned around and yanked out my earbuds. My roommate stood in the kitchen doorway in her oversized sweatshirt, one sock on, one sock off, glasses tilted on her nose.
“Good morning to you too,” I said.
We had met in college at NYU and moved in together after graduation out of pure necessity—two broke girls, one extremely questionable job market. That was four years ago, and now we probably could’ve afforded our own places, but at this point, living together felt less like convenience and more like a long-term bit.
“You’re happily awake and singing, Cass.” Priya shuffled in and reached for a mug. I poured her a cup of coffee before she could ask.
“It’s Mariah,” I said. “What am I supposed to do, listen and not sing along?”
Priya had known about my Christmas obsession before we moved in together, but in her loving words, she hadn’t “realized it might be something that required an intervention.”
“The sun’s not even up.”
“She doesn’t have a time restriction, Priya. That’s what makes her timeless.” I handed her a bowl. “Help me bake?”
After a sigh and a long sip of coffee, she said, “I’m still half asleep, but sure.”
My dad used to say I could bake in my sleep, and that was probably true. So far, my sleepwalking résumé included reorganizing the bathroom cabinet at age fourteen and once waking up in the hallway holding a banana like I had somewhere important to take it.
Sleep baking didn’t feel wildly out of reach.
Dad had been the one to teach me how to bake. We spent Sunday mornings in our kitchen on the Upper West Side, flour on every surface, him narrating each step in the overly serious tone he reserved for things he loved.
He was also the one who taught me to hold my anticipation until December first, because Thanksgiving deserved its moment, too.
I turned the oven on, the click-click-whoosh filling the kitchen, and we got to work.
Sugar crystals scattered as the scent of cinnamon and vanilla bloomed in the air. Priya wasn’t the most coordinated in the kitchen, but she could follow instructions.
An hour later, the first batch of snickerdoodles was cooling on the rack, their tops crackled perfectly, edges just crisp enough to promise a soft center. I poured myself a coffee, leaned against the counter, and let myself have exactly thirty seconds of pure, uncomplicated happiness.