Page 72
They shoved her luggage in the rusty old station wagon that rarely left the parking garage they paid monthly for. Zara and Julia both held a suitcase on their laps, but she didn’t mind because she was home.
She watched dreamily from the car as brownstones tangled in string lights and corner bodegas with handwritten holiday signs passed them by. Couples, cheeks pink from the cold, huddled together.
Zara pressed her forehead to the window and let the city settle in around her. This was her New York. The one she’d been dreaming of. Perfect and unchanged after all of these years.
Their one-bedroom Harlem loft was small. But it smelled like childhood with the scent of her great grandma’s garlicky gravy recipe, clean laundry drying on the terrace, and a candle that probably cost too much but was “worth every cent” according to Julia. The radiator clicked like it had arthritis, the jazz station crackled from the old radio, and every inch of wall space was covered in bookshelves of yellowing music scores.
Zara took her time unpacking her things into the shoebox closet. She hung her audition and performance outfits neatly on their mismatched hangers. Lined up her boots. Folded her jeans. Was thankful she could stow her suitcases under the fold-out couch until she found her own place here.
When she finally collapsed onto the creaky mattress, it let out a sigh so loud it startled the dog from his sunny bed on the wide window sill. Giuseppe, her now-ancient childhood spaniel, climbed into her lap like she hadn’t been gone at all. Zara scratched behind his ears and felt something in her chest start to unwind.
“You didn’t even miss me, huh?” she whispered.
He licked her chin like how couldn’t I?
She buried her face in his familiar fur and replied, “You smell way better than Avery’s cows.”
Outside, a siren wailed. Someone sang “Silver Bells” in the hallway. Her dad argued with Alexa about turning the lamps on. Eventually, the clanging in the kitchen amounted to the three of them seated at the dinner table, Julia pouring wine and Dad serving pasta. Zara lit their ceramic tree centerpiece and watched the flame lick up past the chipped yellow star.
There was no ordeal. There were no raised voices. They didn’t need to make a big deal of things—they just existed together. The way they always had.
“To Zara’s return home.” Dad raised his glass.
“Mazel,” Julia agreed.
They clinked their glasses together, and whatever remained of the worry and tension in Zara’s shoulders melted away.
She was back.
“Leaving in ten, Z!” her Dad’s muffled voice called from the other side of the bathroom door.
“I’ll be right out!” Zara called back, toothbrush wedged in her mouth.
She leaned closer to the mirror, the same one she’d squinted into as a child when she was first learning to braid her hair. Time had been busy in this glass. It had watched her acne come and go, braces gleam, eyeliner disasters, tear-streaked nights, and the beginnings of laugh lines that now lingered, carved as much by grief as by joy. This mirror had seen the light fade from her green eyes—and had seen it fight its way back again.
Zara spit, rinsed, and swung the door open just in time for his scolding to dissolve. Dad’s expression softened instantly, admiration replacing annoyance.
“My beautiful girl,” he murmured, as if the sight of her still startled him. “All grown up.”
“I thought we were late,” she teased, brushing past.
“We are.” He grabbed the case waiting by the door and hoisted it onto his shoulder.
They took the A train downtown, shuffling into a car packed with bundled commuters and tourists herding piles of shopping bags. Zara would like to say the air smelled like roasting chestnuts and opportunity, but really it just smelled like too many people crammed in a small space. She pressed gloved fingers against the cool silver pole and let her father’s steady presence anchor her.
He told her about the winter soiree they’d booked—how one of his bingo buddies was on the board and had begged them to perform together, just like old times. Zara smiled, remembering when she was small enough to perch beside her dad, pretending she was a part of the ensemble.
Back then music had been magic, not a job. There was something so heart-wrenching and complicated about turning your love into your livelihood.
When they made it to the center, Zara was unsurprised to find the art deco exterior decked out in thick evergreen garlands and fat velvet bows. And before too long, the crowd hummed with holiday cheer, tipsy on champagne and the season itself.
As Zara and her dad began to play, the years fell away. They played together as easily as they always had, as though musical interpretation was genetic. At one point, Zara poked fun at the hostess whose dress was tucked into her tights and who carried a strip of toilet paper along under her shoe, but the joke that would have made Blake riff off of her, flopped with her dad who merely scowled and shook his head.
And just like that, she felt the absence she’d been dreading. No one laughing at her lame jokes, no warm hand pressing her favorite coffee into hers. Playing with her dad was a memory, but its predictability reminded her of the way Blake could ignite her. Could bring her to life.
After a well-received cocktail hour, Zara packed up the rented harp and bid her goodbyes to old family friends. Eventually, predictably, they wound their way to their favorite bodega and warmed up with steaming cups of hot chocolate piled indecently high with whipped cream. The night air bit at her cheeks as Zara and her father crossed into the park, settling on their usual bench.
They watched the city parade pass: couples arm in arm, a woman jogging, a harried young mother pushing a stroller. Zara let herself imagine each role as if it belonged to her—the mother, the runner, the street musician busking for rent. This city made every dream seem possible.