AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Open Door

Page 33

by Laurelin Paige

A new sob caught in my throat.

One.

The doors opened, and I felt another rush of relief thatthere wasn’t anyone in the lobby besides the doorman, who was too busy playingwith his phone to notice me. But now I had to wait for my husband and I had nophone of my own, no numbers to watch change on a digital screen, and lots ofbuzzy buzzy noise in my head, begging for attention.

I paced, counting the steps it took to get to the other sideof the lobby and back to the elevator. Twenty-seven to get to the outsidedoors. My stride quickened on the way back and it only took twenty-four. Backto the outside doors was twenty-five.

Just as I pivoted to make my return, the elevator doorsopened, and there was JC, looking as sharp and handsome as ever, his expressiontight, his hair a mess from...well, probably from someone running their fingersthrough it. Had it been him? Had it been me?

Fuck, had it been Shoshanna?

I was too wrapped up in the answer to remember to bow myhead, and our eyes caught. His features softened ever so slightly, but hismouth stayed tight. Was that regret? Pity?

I didn’t want to guess almost as much as I didn’t want toknow.

My gaze dropped to my feet and stayed there until he’dwalked the twenty-seven/twenty-five steps to get to me, then I pushed throughthe glass door out into the spring night.

Except for when JC offered to give me his jacket, which Ideclined, we were quiet on the way home. The party had only been located threeblocks away from our apartment, so we walked. The sounds of New York Citytraffic and the clip, clip, clip of my heels on the pavement made the silencefeel less tense than if we’d been trapped together in a car, but it wasn’tenough distraction to keep my head occupied.

What had Shoshanna said? She was surely angry. I’d left herwith serious blue balls after she’d been so generous to me.

I was a terrible lover.

The Open Door would probably cancel our membership.

Had JC tried to give an explanation for me? What had hesaid to Shoshanna? Had their parting been awkward? Had he kissed her goodbye?

The knot in my stomach grew so tight I thought I might throwup.

God, what a mess I’d made.

Inside our apartment, I headed straight for our bedroom,wanting to be out of my clothes. Wanting to be out of my skin. JC followed onmy heels, and before I could escape into my closet, he snagged my elbow, hisgrip firm and anchoring.

“Gwen, if you don’t want to talk, can I say some things?”

I ignored the gentle tug inviting me into his arms. “Can Itake a shower first? Please?”

He didn’t answer, and he didn’t let me go. I braved myselfand lifted my eyes to find he was studying me with concern.

He wasn’t mad at me. Or he wasn’t as mad as he was worried.Of course he wouldn’t be. He loved me. I knew that. I knew that.

It felt good to remind myself of that.

“We’ll talk after,” I said, my voice softer. “I promise.”First, I had to figure out what I was going to say.

He nodded then, his lips twitching like he wanted to benddown and kiss my head but also wanted to respect my boundaries.

Respect won, and he let me go. “I’ll be here if you needme,” he said as I closed the bathroom door on him for the second time thatnight.

This time, I managed not to sink to the floor, despite myinsides feeling like lead. Mechanically, I kicked off my shoes and stripped offmy dress, leaving it in a pile where it fell on the marble floor, then Istepped into the walk-in shower, stood under the hot water, and let my braintry to unwind the tangle that I’d made.

The problem was that I hadn’t made a firm decision to breakour rule of no sharing before I’d broken it. Alayna had warned me about that.

The problem was that I was selfish and insecure and couldn’thandle my husband touching another woman, no matter how certain I was of hislove.

The problem was that I was too consumed with finding theultimate erotic high when we’d been perfectly happy with what we’d alreadyfound.

The problem was that I’d talked to JC but not really. Not asmuch as I should have. Not specifically about what might happen if we invitedsomeone else into our bed. Not about whether or not it was something we bothwanted. I’d made the decision on my own, and that wasn’t how we worked best. Weworked best together.