Page 124
She nods and allows Felix to help her from the couch. As they move toward the kitchen, I put my notes aside and consider what I've witnessed.
Delaney understood the scientific explanation. She followed the evidence, remembered the terminology and asked relevant questions. Her distress began only when I invited her to express an independent opinion.
The distinction is significant.
She's been taught that knowledge belongs to whoever possesses authority and that disagreement carries consequences. Asking her what she thinks isn't merely an academic exercise. To Delaney, it may feel like a test she could be punished for failing.
I make a note to approach open-ended questions differently in future.
When I return from the kitchen with a glass of water, Delaney is examining the textbook I've left on the coffee table.
She's leaning forward, one hand resting beside the page while the other hovers over a diagram of Earth's interior. Her expression is intensely focused, and she doesn't notice me until I sit in the armchair. "How do they know what's inside Earth if nobody has been there?" she asks, looking up.
I smile, pleased that her curiosity hasn't been diminished by our earlier difficulty. "Scientists use several methods. One of the most important involves studying seismic waves produced by earthquakes."
"How does that tell them what's underground?"
I reach for my pencil, intending to sketch a simple diagram in the margin of the textbook.
Delaney gasps. "You're going to write in it!"
I stop, looking from the pencil to her face. "Yes?"
"But it's a book."
"I'm aware."
"You can't write in books."
I consider her objection. "Annotating textbooks can be useful. It allows us to record questions, highlight important information and connect ideas."
She looks genuinely horrified. "That's horrible."
I make a conscious effort not to smile at the strength of her reaction. "All right," I concede, placing the pencil on the table. "No writing in textbooks." I retrieve a yellow notepad from my satchel and hold it up. "Would this be acceptable?"
She examines it before nodding. "Yes. That's what paper is for."
"Excellent. We've established our first classroom rule."
Delaney looks intrigued. "We have?"
"No writing in textbooks."
She smiles, and I find myself smiling back. It's a small exchange, but an encouraging one. She's disagreed with something I intended to do, explained why she disliked it, and watched me accommodate her preference without argument.
I suspect experiences like this will teach her considerably more about personal autonomy than any explanation I could provide.
The laptop proves to be an entirely different experience.
I place it on the coffee table and open the lid, explaining that computers can be used to access information, write documents, communicate with people and conduct research.
Delaney leans forward, watching the screen illuminate. "Does it have everything in it?"
"Not quite everything," I reply. "But it can access an extraordinary amount of information."
"How?"
"Through the internet."