Page 65
Somehow, her silence was the best thing she could have given me.
That made the pull between us sudden and undeniable. It felt like a physical gravity, drawing us toward each other across the expanse of the kitchen island.
Neither of us moved, yet the space between us seemed to shrink.
It made the tension in the room feel twice as thick, twice as dangerous, as if a single step forward would change everything, and there would be no going back.
Angel cleared her throat, breaking the heavy silence. She was probably sensing that we had crossed an invisible line, though her eyes remained intensely focused on mine.
“So, um, now that you’re not going into work …” She cocked her head. “Did you have any other plans for today?”
I reached for my coffee mug, needing a physical distraction. “Just filling us with coffee and toast.”
A small smile curved her lips. “Well, I have an idea—if you’re open to it.”
I squinted at her, a sudden, wary feeling settling in my chest. I strongly suspected I wouldn’t like her suggestion. “If you’re planning on going for a drive to look for that white four-wheel drive, then absolutely not.”
“No, actually. The opposite.” She leaned slightly forward, her expression turning serious. “We can stay right here, and maybe you could let me have a look through Charlotte’s case files.”
I groaned, the sound coming from deep in my chest, and I pushed back from the counter.
“I know I’m probably the last person you want digging into your life,” she said quickly, rising as if to keep me from walking away. “But a fresh set of eyes might see something you’ve grown blind to over the years. And ...” She hesitated, scrunching her nose. “With Bob Ackerman now exposed as a corrupt asshole, every single page of that original investigation has to be scrutinized again. The whole investigation needs to be started from scratch. You know that, don’t you?”
I did. I hated it, but she was right.
I stood there, fighting myself. This time yesterday, I had torn strips off her just for looking in Charlotte’s room. I had spent two decades guarding my sister’s memory like a pitbull on a heavy chain, keeping the world at bay. But Angel investigated cold cases for a living. My brother Parker did, too, and it ate our family alive that our own sister’s case was the one we could never crack.
Looking at Angel now, seeing the determination in her eyes, I ran out of reasons to keep her locked out. “Okay,” I said.
“Okay?” Her brows lifted in surprise, and she winced slightly, touching the dark bruise over her eyebrow. “As in, yes?”
“We’ll need more coffee,” I said, picking up my mug. “You up for another round?”
“Absolutely.” Smiling, she slid her empty mug toward me.
I carried the mugs into the butler’s kitchen, hoping like hell I wouldn’t regret this decision.
“I’ll just go check on my washing,” she called out after me. “Do you want me to hang them on the line?”
“No,” I called back over my shoulder. “Use the dryer. It’s quicker anyway.”
Ten minutes later, we stood side by side in Charlotte’s room, holding our fresh mugs of coffee as our gazes traveled over the walls.
Twenty years of clues were displayed in a system that was both meticulously organized and utterly chaotic. Photos of Charlotte, maps of the bushland where she disappeared, lists of every person Charlotte had known, timelines detailed down to the minute, and colored string stretching from wall to wall, pinning hard facts to desperate theories.
Everything in this space was the physical manifestation of our endless search. It was a silent, heavy obsession that had consumed my life, and Jaxson and Parker’s lives, too.
Along the baseboards, battered cardboard boxes filled with thousands of pages of police reports, witness statements, and transcripts were lined up like headstones in a private cemetery.
I still couldn’t believe I was actually about to let a relative stranger look at these files.
I just hoped my brothers wouldn’t kill me when they found out.
THIRTEEN
ANGEL
Charlotte’s room smelled like an old library, thick with the scent of twenty years of paperwork and accumulating dust.