Page 106
Together, the three of them gave me what details they could. Lola had spent a lot of time at the Callahan house. She’d sat at the dinner table with Clay, the triplets, and Whit’s parents a lot, nearly weekly. They’d all known her well. Or at least they’d thought they had.
My research had taught me that people could be very good at hiding things when they wanted to. Like the lack of an explanation for why Tegan had so much cash in her bedroom that her mother hadn’t known about.
I moved from wall to wall, from photo to photo, reading all the notes on Charlotte, listening to the men, and trying to let my mind loosen rather than forcing it down any one path. That was never how this worked anyway. Cold cases rarely broke open in a straight line. Most of the time, they turned on a tiny detail overlooked the first time around. Or tenth time around. Or someone came forward years later, when guilt finally became too heavy to carry. Or, as in Joey Robbins’s case, his body was found after thirty-seven years in a cave.
That was why I never just looked at the obvious thing in front of me. Like not just the face in the middle of the photo. The background mattered, too.
When the men fell quiet, I asked, “What kind of kid was Lola? Rebellious? Studious? Any drug issues?”
They took turns answering, and by all accounts she sounded like an ordinary seventeen-year-old girl.
“Nothing in the police reports suggests there were drugs at the party,” Whit said. “Though there were empty beer bottles found in the back garden, remember?” He looked at Parker.
“Were they checked for fingerprints?” I asked.
Parker and Whit frowned at each other as they worked through the question. It was almost unnerving how alike they were when they did that. Finally, Parker looked at Whit. “I don’t remember reading that in the report. Do you?”
“No.” Whit crossed to one of the boxes and lifted the lid. Inside was a stack of manila files. He pulled out a section and set it on the table.
As he leafed through those files and Parker joined him, I moved to another wall covered in photos of Charlotte. In every one, she was with friends, smiling or laughing, looking like any other happy, carefree teenager.
Just like Celeste had been.
The ache in my chest deepened.
“Have any of you kept in contact with Lola?” I asked.
Again, the brothers looked at each other, then shook their heads.
“She moved away a couple of years after this,” Parker said. “When she was twenty or twenty-one.”
“Last I heard, she was in Townsville,” Whit added. “Working in aged care.”
I drifted to another section of the wall and read through the newspaper clippings about that night.
The room smelled faintly of coffee and old paper, with the muddy tang of the river drifting in through the flyscreen windows. Outside, the late afternoon had gone still and bright. Somewhere a bird squawked like it was being murdered.
I stopped in front of a photo of Lola standing behind a birthday cake swirled with pink frosting. The candles were lit. Lola was smiling. Beside her, Charlotte was smiling, too.
“Is this the only photo from that party?” I asked no one in particular. “Surely there’d be more.”
“No, there’s a bunch more.” Parker carried over another box and set it on one of the dining chairs before lifting the lid. “Here you go.”
He dropped a fat envelope onto the table. I opened it and tipped dozens of glossy prints out in a messy spill. They were classic disposable-camera shots—grainy, badly framed, full of red-eyed faces caught in the glare of the flash. It was a heartbreaking snapshot of an ordinary teenage birthday party on what had turned out to be the last normal night of two families’ lives. There were party streamers, metallic balloons, bright dresses, sausage rolls, party pies, and a half-eaten birthday cake. Smiles. More smiles.
At first glance, nothing about the party seemed remarkable. The photos were exactly the kind families shoved into old albums and forgot about for years—teenagers in summer clothes, cheap drinks in plastic cups, bursts of laughter caught at the wrong moment, blurred limbs, faces turned half away from the lens. Ordinary, in the way old photographs often were, back before digital cameras made everything look polished and often fake.
As I flipped through them, the men grabbed more beer, Whit included.
“You want one?” he asked. “Or another water?”
“Water, please.”
He set a glass in front of me, then let his gaze drop to the photos. He pulled one toward himself. Charlotte and four other girls had been caught mid-dance, skirts swishing around their legs. Every one of them was smiling.
“Do you know who they are?” I asked.
“That’s Lucy.” He pointed to a girl with a wild mop of red hair. “Jessica and Claire. We didn’t know them before … before that night. We didn’t know many of Charlotte’s friends very well, except Lola. Charlotte had lots of friends. She was always going to parties, or social stuff, or the beach with them. We were all busy with our own things. Sport, school.” He gave a small shake of his head.