AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Thin Line Between Love and Hate

Page 96

by Gwyn McNamee

I can blame it on genetics rather than outside forces…

“You aren’t making any sense, Mom. Why would I have recognized Ellis Thatcher? I never met the man before Father died.”

“Well, maybe you never met the man but you certainly knew the boy. You used to babysit for him. ‘Ellis’ was his maternal grandmother’s maiden name, which is why I assume he chose it for his new identity, though I have no idea where the ‘Thatcher’ came from. You’d have to ask him…” She trails off, lost in thought for a moment. “You really never noticed that your next door neighbor is the same one who has always lived there—August Foster?”

An icy blast shoots through my veins, instantly vanquishing all the warmth I’ve been luxuriating in after last night. “Augie?”

“Yes, dear.” Her continued annoyance with me tenses her words. “When I was back in The States several years ago, you know, when we got together for lunch, I swung through Cape Blackwell to see some old acquaintances and ran into him. He was introduced to me as Dwight’s new business partner, but I knew exactly who he was the moment I laid eyes on him. Those baby blues give him away.”

Images of the little boy who used to stare up at me with so much affection when I read him bed time stories and of the man I spent the night with last night bombard my head.

Oh, my God…

“Mom, no. You must be wrong⁠—”

“I’m not. I know he and his father never truly got along, so I guess it shouldn’t surprise me that he wanted to change his name and have nothing to do with him. I’m frankly surprised you didn’t do the same after you stopped speaking to Marcellus. But he’s taken the whole ‘recreating himself’ thing a little too far, if you ask me.”

She must be wrong.

This has to be a mistake.

A massive misunderstanding.

There wouldn’t be any reason for August Foster to lie to me about who he is. Especially not after last night. Not after being in that house. Not after what happened between us.

Someone says something to Mother, and her peal of laughter pierces the line before she returns. “I have to run, dear. Sorry we couldn’t chat longer. Ta ta for now.”

She ends the call before I can respond, leaving me sitting in stunned silence, my head spinning in a thousand different directions but none of them seem to be the right one.

That woman has to be wrong.

There must be some confusion on her part.

Some reasonable explanation for her very wrong belief…

A barely audible click sounds in the study, and I whip my head toward the left wall and the floor-to-ceiling bookcases that hold Father’s priceless book collection.

At first, nothing appears amiss, but the edge of one section begins to slide backward until it disappears into the wall.

My breath catches, goosebumps breaking out across my already chilled skin…

Before I can react, Ellis steps into the office through the secret door, his blue eyes that are always so warm and inviting now icy and cold as they lock on me. “I heard your phone call with your mother.” He slowly wanders over to the chess table, dressed in one of his bespoke suits, and unbuttons the coat to take a seat on the white side, crossing one leg over the other knee casually. “It’s unfortunate she called today. We’re still”—he glances at the chess set—“five moves away from completing our game, but I guess your mother has forced my play.”

I try to form words, struggle to get my brain to fire and to process everything I was told and what my eyes just saw, but it doesn’t want to compute.

None of it makes any sense.

Ellis offers a cool smile. “I’ve been watching you for a very long time, Lorelei Whitley. And it took a lot of work, a lot of effort, to get you back here. To get you in this position. It’s time for you to pay for your sins.”