AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Thin Line Between Love and Hate

Page 71

by Gwyn McNamee

At ten, I learned what I was worth to both of them. And it stole that last little bit of my heart that clung to the naïve belief that deep down, they loved me, even if they weren’t capable of showing it, and crushed it into dust.

The affection I never saw in their eyes fills Ellis’ as he watches me from across the room, undoubtedly fighting the desire to come and pull me into his arms as he has done so many times since we met. “I’m so sorry, Lorelei. I don’t even know what to say to that.”

I tamp down the emotion that wants to overwhelm me.

If I let it take over, I’ll never get through this and say what I need to for him to understand how any of this plays into what he’s asked me to do.

“It’s all right, really. I’ve had twenty-plus years to process all of this and understand that my mother and I are better off as casual acquaintances who sometimes catch up via telephone. I haven’t seen her in person in …God…” It takes me far too long to remember the last time she was in the States and contacted me. “Five or six years. She’s always gallivanting around Europe or sailing in the Mediterranean or wherever her new beau happens to be from, bouncing from one billionaire to another, one yacht to another. Always finding her free ride because the money Father gave her is long gone.”

Ellis swirls his drink and takes a sip of it, offering a grimace that has nothing to do with the exceedingly expensive alcohol. “I’m surprised he left her anything in the will.”

I snort. “I’m not.”

“Why?”

“Because it was written into their agreement that she got a second payout at his death.”

He rolls his eyes, tipping his head back against the marble fireplace behind him. “Of course it was. Then, I’m surprised that she hasn’t called, trying to collect.”

“Oh, she will.” I resume my pacing, unable to stand still any longer when my nerves are making it feel like thousands of bugs are crawling over my skin. “There’s no way that woman is going to miss a chance to collect money like that. No chance in Hell. But she’s had shitty phone service. I’ve tried to connect with her multiple times since I returned here and only got through three times to a bad connection where I could make out maybe a few words she was saying. I’m sure as soon as she’s somewhere that she can make a call that has a bank and a notary, the first call will be to you to get her fucking money.” I try to rein in my anger and hurt, knowing what I’m going to have to tell him requires me to maintain some semblance of control over my emotions, but it is proving harder than I imagined. “But that’s not why I’m telling you this, Ellis. This isn’t about her; it’s about what growing up in that kind of environment did to me.”

“What do you mean?”

I release a deep sigh, bracing myself for what’s coming. “My father was a cold man who wanted nothing to do with me unless it benefitted him somehow. He left me to be raised mostly by Eliza, his housekeeper, and he only talked to me when he had a lesson to teach me or to tear into me because of some perceived misstep on my part. That. Man. Was. Ice.”

A shiver rolls through me, as if I can feel his cool gaze locked on me now. Judging. Dressing me down without a word. Ensuring I saw his hatred and displeasure in me.

“It made me cold too, Ellis. Just. Like. Him. The apple did not fall far from that tree.”

Chapter 19

Lorelei

Ellis works his tense jaw, watching me from across the room as he considers my words. A thousand different emotions flash across his consuming gaze, each one more unreadable than the previous, as if what I just said threw him off balance and has him questioning things he thought he understood.

For all the time we’ve spent together, and despite Ellis always being an open book, I can’t read him right now. But there’s a tension I don’t often see. This is exactly why I was dreading this conversation. We haven’t even reached the confession portion, and Ellis is already hedging, already seeing me differently.

I try to look away, to save myself from having to watch him slowly pull away from me, but his voice cutting through the air forces me to keep my eyes on his.

“You are far from cold, Lorelei.” There it is again—that conviction with which he says so many things I am so unsure about. “Maybe you should be with the way your life began and growing up in these walls with your father, but you are not. The first thing you did when you inherited the Whitley fortune was attend a fundraiser where you knew you would be surrounded by people you hate who would want to see you uncomfortable to deliver an incredibly generous check you were under no obligation to provide. And your second act as the Whitley heir was to create your own charity, to do good with all this wealth that benefits no one but you, otherwise. When you smile, it lights up a room. Your presence in my life has burned through so many inhibitions and incinerated all the reasons I should have acknowledged and accepted to keep my distance. I am the moth and you are the flame, Lorelei. You. Are. Not. Cold.”

I wish I could believe his words. I wish I could luxuriate in them and let them become my reality, but even if they are true about who I have become since leaving Cape Blackwell, they couldn’t be more wrong about who Lorelei Whitley was before that.

“I was, Ellis, back then. I was the mean girl with my group of friends at our fancy private grade school on the bay. We made fun of the scholarship kids; the son of the janitor who got a free ride, the daughter of the principal’s secretary, anyone who wasn’t like us. Anyone who didn’t look like us, or talk like us, or act like us, or have the kind of money we did.” The harsh, unkind words I said to them and so many others over the years echo through my head. “I was friends with the daughters of some of those people we sat at that dinner table with the other night.”

His dark brows draw low, and it’s no wonder he’s confused considering they never hinted at that connection the entire evening. The conversation always circled back to Father or the Manor, my plans for the future and the money rather than the past I’m sure they’d all like to keep there. “You were?”

I nod. “Katie Evangelista, Lindsay Winslow, Anna Farley, and of course, Natalie. That was our core group. We played horrible tricks on people. Pranks that we laughed at and justified in our heads as harmless. We ratted out other kids just to watch them get punished. Tore other people down any way we could. We did really stupid, really mean shit, and we didn’t care. About them or about anything but ourselves.”

Looking back, with decades of self-awareness and reflection now under my belt, it is so easy to see that I was making them feel my pain, so I didn’t have to.

The harsh words Father spoke to me became my insults to them. The disrespect I showed others was the same he and Mother gave me. But at the time, I was too wrapped up in the thrill of being a step above everyone else that I saw nothing wrong with how I hurt other people.

Ellis tilts his head. “What happened between you and Natalie? I know it had to be more than just regretting what you two did as kids.”

I knew the question would come. I knew that at some point, if I opened up about this, I would have to tell him everything, but it’s far more awkward and painful than I thought it would be.

Especially standing in this house, where it all happened…