Page 26

Someone was dead. Nolan, probably. The man who had raised me with cruelty and claimed the right to break me was gone, and I felt nothing. No grief. No relief. Just the hollow recognition that his death changed nothing about the lie I had been living.

I shoved the photographs and recorder back into the envelope with shaking hands. My entire identity had been built on a deception meant to protect the people who should have protected me. Every promise they had made—every assurance that family would keep me safe if only I trusted them—had been a lie wrapped around an older, deeper lie that had shaped the architecture of my entire existence.

They had no right to ask for my trust. They had forfeited that right the moment they chose to let Nolan claim me as his daughter while my real father stood close enough to touch and never knew.

Returning to my room, I dressed with mechanical precision, pulling on jeans and a sweater while my mind continued to rewrite my childhood. Every moment with Cian took on new weight—his steady presence, his unconditional love, the way he had looked at me as though I mattered. He had been my father all along, and neither of us had been allowed to know it.

The devastation of that realization was almost worse than learning about Nolan. Because Nolan’s cruelty had always been a known quantity—something I had learned to survive, to navigate, to endure. But Cian’s love had been the one constant in my life, the one relationship I had believed was uncomplicated and true.

And it had been built on a lie.

But now I had proof. Photographs of my mother and Cian together, nine months before I was born. A tape recording of the moment the truth had been revealed—Nolan’s rage, Uncle Sal’s shock, Cian’s devastation at learning he had a daughter he’d never known about.

Evidence of a betrayal that encompassed my entire existence.

I shoved the envelope into my purse, left my grandfather’s house without making the bed, and locked the front door behind me. The strap dug into my shoulder as I descended the steps, the truth resting against my ribs like a wound someone had finally given a name.

The ride to Duncan’s passed in fragments—brick buildings, traffic lights, blurred faces beyond the window. By the time the car stopped, anger had burned through the last of my hesitation, leaving behind a terrible clarity that felt more dangerous than rage.

This was inevitable. This confrontation had been building since the moment I learned to keep secrets, since the first time Nolan raised his hand and I refused to tell my family, since I chose to disappear from Henry’s life rather than trust the people who promised to protect me.

They had been lying to me my entire life. And before I allowed any of them to speak about love, protection, or trust again, they were going to tell me why I had been forced to build my entire existence upon their lie.

I climbed the steps to Duncan’s house with my purse tucked beneath my arm, the photographs and recorder—along with the truth—heavy inside. Everyone who had called themselves my family waited beyond that door—the people who had watched me grow up beneath a violent man’s hand, who had let me believe cruelty was my inheritance, who had promised they would have protected me if only I had trusted them.

The truth had waited long enough.

I had waited even longer.

CHAPTER SEVEN

April 2025, Boston

Storming into Duncan and Freyja’s house with such force that the door slammed against the wall behind it, I found Cian sitting in the living room and asked, “Did you know?”

The quietness of my voice frightened me more than a scream. Rage had burned itself cold, leaving my hands trembling with the effort not to break.

Panic crossed Cian’s face before he concealed it. His gaze darted behind me toward Mom, and that one glance told me the truth had already lived between them while I remained outside it.

“Maddie—”

The sound of my name in his voice felt like another theft. I’d heard him say it with affection all my life, yet now even that familiarity carried the weight of every lie I had been told.

“Did. You. Know?” I asked again, my voice trembling as I forced each word through a throat that was rapidly closing around the tears I was desperately trying to hold back.

Freyja rushed toward me before Duncan caught her hand. Concern softened her face as she asked, “Know what, sweetie?”

“That he is my father!” The declaration tore through the room, leaving a silence so complete I heard Mom’s breath catch behind me. Cian’s eyes closed as his head lowered. The absence of denial struck harder than the gunshot on the recording.

“You knew!” Every kindness he’d shown me rearranged itself into something I no longer understood. I searched the room and found guilt, shock, and pity on the faces of people who had spent the last few months asking why I didn’t trust them. “You all knew!”

Uncle Sal stepped toward me. “Maddie, honey.” His voice held a gentleness that might have soothed me any other day, but tenderness from people who kept secrets had begun to feel like another form of control.

“No, Uncle Sal. Someone should have told me!” My grief sharpened the words until they wounded us both.

“I didn’t know, Maddie. Not for sure.” Cian’s voice wavered.

His answer should have mattered, but uncertainty was only a softer kind of silence when my identity was at stake. I turned toward Mom. Her hands covered her mouth, and terror filled her face as though she had been waiting years for this moment and had still found no way to survive it.