AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Trick or Treat Me

Page 32

by Sienne Vega

“I wasn’t worried.”

“You should’ve been. I was prepared to keep going.”

A vague dark smile touches his mouth, his only real answer.

We continue washing, soon with me under the spray of water.

My thoughts wander to how I went years working at Terror Acres hearing about the terrifying Skeleton Man, unknowing that he was alive in the flesh.

But not only that, he was watching out for me. He showed up the moment I was in trouble, and he did what he had to do to save me.

I’d always thought of that night at Terror Acres as surviving the Skeleton Man and his violence.

But for so long I’ve been mistaken, the trauma distorting my memory. What I really survived was Mr. Herman and his.

The Skeleton Man had been the one to help me do so.

Milo reaches for the soap and lathers it between his palms. His touch glides smoothly across my shoulder, gentle once he reaches the patches of skin scratched by branches and roughened by tree bark. Each mark tightens his jaw. He washes the dirt from my arms before easing me back around to reach other body parts.

Tenderness comes naturally to him, even after everything he did tonight.

I let my head tip back while he rinses the mud from the ends. Water runs over my closed eyelids, shutting out the candles and his face. With only his hands to concentrate on, I marvel at the fact that I’ve spent years terrified of him.

I’ve lived my life in complete and total fear because of that night.

Most days, I spend my time in solitude. Patients fill my computer screen from morning until late afternoon, trusting me with marriages, grief, fears, and secrets they’ve never shared aloud. Then the final appointment ends, my laptop closes, and the entire house falls silent.

I rarely leave my house, and I stopped keeping in touch with most people outside my mother and other close relatives.

I called that life peaceful because lonely sounded like an admission of failure.

The security system and five locks helped me pretend isolation was a decision rooted entirely in safety. Every October, I watched the anniversary creep closer and imagined relief waiting on November first. Another year would pass without the Skeleton Man fulfilling his promise, proving I’d escaped the past.

Relief never came.

The jack-o’-lantern on my porch frightened me because the message confirmed that he had returned. After five years of living in paranoia, trying so hard to forget, that was no longer an option.

The past had finally caught up with me, and I was going to remember that wretched night whether I wanted to or not.

But it’s fortunate that I have in the darkest, most twisted way. I’ve finally been made to confront the fear I was so desperate to spend my life avoiding.

Milo draws me back against his chest. His arms circle my waist while the shower cools around us, and his mouth brushes the curve where my neck meets my shoulder.

“You said I’m coming with you,” I murmur.

His lips still against my skin. “I want you to.”

The honesty draws my eyes open. I turn within his hold until we face each other, water tracing the strong planes of his cheeks.

“What happens if I stay?”

Pain tightens his features before he brings them back under control and they relax. “I leave before sunrise.”

“After everything you did to get here?”

“I came back to give you the choice we didn’t get five years ago.” His thumb passes over my cheek. “I won’t make it for you.”

The answer strips away the final excuse available to me. If Milo tried to force me into leaving, I could blame him for whatever came next. Remaining here would be easier to justify if the decision were taken out of my hands.