Page 29
I slow near the front door and exchange one last uncertain glance at him. Then we’re entering the house together, steps in tandem.
Gale-force winds slam the door shut behind us, minimizing the roar of the rain to a heavy drumming against the roof. Water drips from our clothes onto the hardwood, pooling on the floorboards.
Trixie peers from under the dining table. Her ears flatten when she spots the man behind me, but she doesn’t run. A low warning sound rumbles in her throat before she retreats farther into the shadows.
My hand moves toward the dead bolt out of habit.
I stop before touching it.
Locking the door would mean locking myself inside with him.
The thought finally cracks through the numbness that carried me out of the woods. I turn to face him.
“What do you want?”
He goes still, studying me in eerie silence.
“I’ve run. I’ve screamed. I’ve done everything you wanted me to do tonight,” I say shakily. “So tell me what comes next.”
Understanding settles over me with the cold weight of rain-soaked clothing.
“This is about the police. You came back because I spoke to them.”
His shoulders tighten.
“I was covered in Mr. Herman’s blood. They kept questioning me, and I told them what I saw because I didn’t know what else to do. If you’ve spent five years planning to kill me for it, then stop dragging this out.”
He takes one step closer.
The floor creaks under his weight.
My stomach knots, but I don’t retreat. There’s nowhere left to go that he can’t follow.
“Go ahead,” I whisper. “Do it.”
He holds the knife up, letting a few seconds pass us by, before opening his hand and letting the blade fall.
It clatters to the floor, the abrupt sound making me flinch.
He reaches up behind his head and pulls at the skull mask that’s hidden his identity for so long.
At six-foot-two with a broad chest and shoulders, he towers over me. But as soon as the skull mask is gone, I realize he’s as human as I am.
His dark hair is dripping wet, some strands at rest against his brow. He uses his other hand to slide fingers through and push them back out of his face, his deep blue eyes hooked on mine.
He has large, masculine features and a deep scar that zigzags down his cheek. Even with the imperfection, he’s attractive. He’s fine.
My lungs forget how to work.
The rumors at Terror Acres said the Skeleton Man was a disgruntled former employee come back from the dead to haunt the theme park.
Turns out, that was nothing more than an urban legend. But that still doesn’t answer the most obvious question at the top of my mind.
“Who… who are you?” I ask, voice barely above a whisper. “I need to know.”
“Milo,” he answers. “Milo Herman.”
“Wait… what…?”