Page 40

Not the good quiet. This was the hollow quiet of absence. Sawyer was at the regional teacher conference out of town. Mikey was covering an extra shift at the bank because someone had called in sick. That left the house to me, to the fire crackling low in the living room grate, and to JJ. And JJ wasn’t making any noise at all, which was the part that didn’t make sense.

I’d been moving through the downstairs for twenty minutes, straightening things that didn’t need straightening, refilling my coffee mug twice. Bola was asleep on the arm of the sofa with his paws tucked under his chest, the picture of feline indifference. I checked my email. I checked the fire. I stood in the kitchen and drank coffee and listened to the house breathe.

No thumping down the stairs. No voice calling questions from another room. No sudden burst of music.

I climbed the stairs slowly, one hand on the banister, coffee mug warm against my palm. The hallway upstairs was quiet too. Mikey’s door was closed. Sawyer’s was ajar, the room neat the way he always left it, bed made with military corners. I passed both and stopped at JJ’s door, which was open about halfway.

He was sitting cross-legged on his bed with the velvet throw bunched around his hips, a math textbook open in his lap that he clearly hadn’t looked at in some time. His blond hair was unbrushed, falling across his forehead in a way that made him look younger than twenty-eight. The cereal bowl on his nightstand had been abandoned. The milk had gone cloudy and the cereal had sunk to the bottom in a pale, sodden mass. He hadn’t even bothered to put it in the kitchen. He was just sitting there. Not reading. Not scheming. Not performing.

His shoulders were pulled in. Not the theatrical slouch he put on when he wanted me to notice he was sulking. His fingers were working at a loose thread on the edge of the throw, twisting it around his index finger until the skin went white, then releasing it, then twisting it again. I stood in the doorway and watched him for a moment. He hadn’t noticed me yet. The afternoon light came through his window and caught the dust motes in the air, turning them gold.

I stepped into the room. Set my coffee mug on his desk, beside the stack of graded papers he’d brought home from school. Sat on the edge of his bed. He didn’t look up. The thread twisted around his finger again.

I waited.

“Mikey left his doll on the couch,” he said finally. His voice was aiming for casual and missing by a mile. “Teresa. Just sitting there by herself. Kind of creepy, honestly. Like that horror movie where the doll…”

He stopped. The joke died before it reached the punchline. His mouth closed. He went back to the thread.

I didn’t let it go.

“What’s going on, JJ?”

He looked at the textbook in his lap, Algebra II, the unit on polynomials, a chapter he could teach in his sleep, and his thumb pressed down on the corner of the page.

“Nothing’s going on,” he said. “Just having a quiet day. Is that illegal now? Do I need to file paperwork?”

“Try again.”

He was quiet for so long I thought he might actually refuse. His thumb kept pressing that corner.

Then he said, to the textbook, “I’m not like Mikey.”

I waited.

“Mikey always knows what you need before you even say it. He’s—” His fingers stilled on the throw. “He does everything right and he does it quietly and he never makes anything harder than it has to be.” He paused. “And Sawyer’s never late. Never out of line twice. Never has to be reminded.” Another pause, shorter. “And then there’s me. I’m always too loud. I’m always too fast, too much, always starting something that makes more work for everyone else, and I know you think it’s funny sometimes, I know you’re not—” He stopped. Swallowed. Picked up the thread on the throw again and pulled it. “I’m afraid you’re going to get tired of me.”

He said it to the blanket. He didn’t look at me.

I was still for a moment. Not because I didn’t know what to say, but because I wanted to say it right — because JJ, who could take a cane set and come back smiling, who could be corrected and turn the correction into a game and make the whole room laugh, was sitting in front of me with his heart in his hands and a voice like he’d been carrying this weight for a while and hadn’t known where to put it down. He was comparing the best parts of his brothers to everything he disliked about himself and believing that was somehow fair.

I said, “You noticed that Max was overwhelmed before anyone else in the room did. Three weeks ago, at the open house. You took him somewhere quieter before he had to ask.”

He didn’t say anything.

“You stayed up until two in the morning the Tuesday before Mikey’s quarterly review helping him prep. You didn’t tell me. He didn’t tell me. I know because I got up for water and I heard the two of you in the kitchen, going over his talking points, and when I looked in you had a whiteboard out and Mikey was in his pajamas taking notes on a Post-it.” I paused. “He got exceptional marks on that review.”

JJ’s hands had gone still.

“You have never, not once in the years I’ve known you, let one of your brothers go to bed thinking something was wrong between you and them, even when they’d driven you out of your mind all day, even when they tattled something to me and got you in trouble. Even when they deserved it. You don’t let people feel forgotten.” I turned toward him fully. “You think I don’t notice that. I notice everything you do. I always have.”

He pressed his lips together. His eyes had gone bright, the brightness that in JJ preceded the point of no return by about thirty seconds.

“You are not your brothers,” I said. “You are yourself. You’re exactly who I want.”

He didn’t say anything. He looked down at the throw, at the loose thread he’d been pulling, and took one breath. The textbook slid off his lap onto the bed. He didn’t move to catch it.

I reached for him.