AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Trick or Treat Me

Page 3

by Elisa Leigh

The house is quiet around me, Kayla fast asleep in her room upstairs. Outside my window, the dark yard and driveway stretch toward the quiet street, but I'm not looking outside. My eyes are locked on the illuminated screen of my smartphone.

A notification from Veil sits pinned to the center of my display.

New Matched Candidate: Verified.

I didn't search for anyone by name. The app generates matches based on compatible preferences, boundaries, location, and verified screening. I submitted my profile weeks ago and haven't thought much about it since.

I touch the screen, opening the newly approved profile.

The primary image loads. The woman wears a black Venetian half-mask trimmed in scalloped lace, but the mask can't conceal the delicate tilt of her chin, the slight fullness of her cheeks, or the plush, rosy bottom lip that she's captured between small, neat teeth. It's Ms. Hartley.

I signed up for Veil three weeks ago. After fourteen months of wanting a woman I couldn't have, I figured it was time to do something about it. Not pursue Ms. Hartley. That wasn't an option. She was Kayla's teacher, and I wasn't about to complicate my daughter's life or put her career at risk.

I needed a distraction. Something uncomplicated. Anonymous. No expectations, no possibility of someone showing up at my office or getting attached to a man who barely had time to date. I'd filled out the profile one night after Kayla went to bed, then promptly forgotten about it.

No one interested me enough to bother responding.

Until now.

Because apparently the universe has a twisted sense of humor.

The one woman I joined this damn app to forget is staring back at me from behind a black lace mask.

Her long, dark brown hair cascades over soft, creamy shoulders in loose, natural waves. Below her collarbones, the camera frames the generous curve of breasts that push against the neckline of a simple navy silk camisole.

A dark, electric jolt travels straight from the base of my skull down to my groin.

I don't need a full photograph to be certain. I've spent the last fourteen months cataloging Megan Hartley. Since Kayla started first grade and I walked into that bright, welcoming classroom for the first time, I've been watching her.

I noticed her patience the day she knelt beside Kayla's desk for ten minutes, gently coaxing my anxious daughter through a math problem she was convinced she couldn't solve. I noticed the way she remembers small details about every student—who loves dinosaurs, who's afraid of thunderstorms, who needs an extra moment of encouragement before trying something new.

It was during a field day last spring when I realized my attention had changed. I was running the relay station when a first-grader's shoelaces came undone mid-race. I knelt in the grass, tied the child's shoes, and sent him back into the game. When I stood and brushed the grass from my knees, I caught Megan watching me. She smiled—warm, a little self-conscious—and something in my chest tightened.

That was the moment I knew I wasn't just noticing her anymore.

I would have volunteered for field day regardless. I would have donated extra art supplies, covered the cost of the fall festival, and quietly paid for field-trip fees through the office whether Megan Hartley existed or not. Kayla's mother and I divorced before Kayla started school, and my daughter's stability is non-negotiable. Being present, being generous, being the father she deserves—that's not negotiable either.

Lauren and I built a stable co-parenting rhythm long ago, and she has since remarried. Her husband, Andrew Bennett, is a kind, reliable stepfather who treats Kayla with genuine care and patience. I don't harbor an ounce of resentment toward their relationship; Kayla is happy, secure, and loved in both of our households, and that is what matters.

But I'd be lying if I said I didn't welcome every legitimate opportunity a classroom party or school event gave me to see Megan.

Every parent-teacher conference. Every brief conversation in the brightly decorated corridors of her school. I know the precise pitch of her voice when she's trying to sound composed. I know the way her brown eyes darken when she's flustered. I know the soft, warm scent of vanilla and clean rain that drifts from her skin.

And I know the agonizing restraint it's taken—for more than a year now—not to cross the line with my daughter's teacher.

Then Megan submitted this profile.

I scroll down, my thumb dragging slowly across the glass, drinking in every word she's confessed.

User Code: Ivy-27

Body Type: Curvy / Thick / Soft

Experience: Limited

My jaw tightens. The self-consciousness in her phrasing makes something possessive tighten in my chest.

I read her answers to the intake questionnaire.