Page 71

Gavin turned his face away.

I loosened my grip on his forearm until my hand was there only as a reminder of the custody I had already declared. He had not tested me once, and the front door seemed to have stopped mattering to him entirely.

Meredith began with the part Georgia and I already knew. Brad had followed her through the service door during the Halloween party seven years ago. Gavin had seen him grab her and intervened. Brad produced the knife; Gavin wrestled it away, threw it aside, and told Meredith to go back inside while he made sure Brad left.

“I did go inside,” she said. “That was true every time I told it. I went back to work, and Gavin came in later. Brad was gone by then, and I thought the night was over.”

She looked past us toward the service door at the far end of the hall. The restaurant had changed owners since then, but the door still opened onto the same alley. I had walked that ground seven years ago, looking at blood on pavement and asking questions that never reached the missing section of the night.

“My roommate and I were supposed to leave together after close,” Meredith continued. “She got held up helping with something inside. I had already put on my coat and gloves, and I went out first because I wanted to get to the car.”

Georgia’s hand slid down my arm until her fingers found mine.

I closed my hand around them.

“Brad was waiting for me,” Meredith said. “He had the knife again. I don’t know exactly when he went back for it, but he must have picked it up after Gavin threw it away.”

Her voice changed when she reached the second confrontation. She did not become more emotional so much as more careful, as if the memory still contained places she had learned not to step without warning.

“He wanted me to go with him. I told him no, and he grabbed me. I tried to get away. He called me names, told me I had made him look weak in front of Gavin, and then he pulled the knife.”

Gavin stared at the floor between us.

Meredith’s fingers tightened over the knit stretched across her stomach.

“I remember getting hold of his wrist. I remember thinking I was going to lose because he was stronger than I was. Then I had the knife. I don’t remember exactly how. I only remember him coming at me again after I got it away from him.”

Georgia’s grip on my hand tightened.

“I stabbed him once,” Meredith said. “I didn’t stand there planning it. I didn’t chase him. I stabbed him because he was coming at me and I thought he was going to kill me.”

The service lights hummed faintly overhead. In the dining room, a burst of applause rose with the music and fell again. Nothing about the restaurant changed to mark the fact that the central assumption behind a seven-year-old murder case had just collapsed.

Meredith swallowed and looked at Georgia.

“He fell. There was blood everywhere, and I panicked. I thought no one would believe me because I had gone back to Brad before. I had told people I was done with him and then taken him back. I thought that would be used against me, and I thought the first fight with Gavin would make everything worse.”

“The gloves,” Georgia said softly.

Meredith nodded. “I was still wearing them.”

That was the detail that took the remaining shape out of the old evidence.

Brad’s usable prints on his own knife had never been strange. Gavin’s prints had been easy to explain until Brad was later found stabbed with the same weapon. Meredith’s absence from the handle had helped the case against Gavin because no one knew she had handled it during a second encounter while wearing gloves.

No elaborate conspiracy or expert cleanup had been required, only cold weather, a frightened woman in a late-October coat, and an incomplete statement.

I looked at Gavin, and he met my eyes without surprise.

Meredith continued before anyone could interrupt her. “I went back inside. By the time the police started asking questions, people already knew Gavin and Brad had fought. I told them about that because I knew I couldn’t hide it. I told them Brad had the knife and Gavin took it away. I told them I went back inside afterward.”

Her mouth trembled.

“I left out everything that happened later.”

Georgia did not release my hand. “And then Gavin was arrested.”

“Yes.”