Page 102 of Where Sinners Repent

Striding over to the table, I wrap my hand around the toy and some lube. They have so much lube that it’s fucking worrying to see. Where are they putting things? And what are they putting in it?

I shudder to think of the less fortunate people who have been between these men.

The black butt plug feels heavy in my hand.

“Don't you fucking dare,” he grits out when he sees it.

I flash him my smile. Using my teeth, I rip open the lube and pour it over the butt plug. Slowly massaging it onto the end.

“What? I thought you'd enjoy this,” I peer at him over my shoulder, turning over to wave the toy in the air.

“Black Cat,” he warns. “Don't.”

“Sorry,” I whisper, putting on an innocent act when I’m anything but, “I can't quite hear you. Are you begging?”

His eye twitches, but his teeth snap shut.

I shrug. Coming to kneel between his legs again, with a lubed-up finger, I feel around for his asshole. If I can be completely honest, I've never shoved a toy in a man's ass before. I've never even shoved a toy up my ass before.

It's all new to me. How hard can it be? It seems pretty self-explanatory...

My finger lands against his back hole, and his entire body tightens. I can't help but give my finger a little shove, working past the resistance. He hisses, and it spurs me on, and I continue to work the rest of my finger through.

I graze something inside him, and his entire body shudders. He's already softening cock jolts. Interesting.

Finally, he tests the strength of the restraints, yanking his arms and pulling a clanking sound from the chains. Maybe they’d come loose if I was the one to secure it, but luckily Leon put his life on the line for me.

I swear he almost welcomes the death that would find him if Kaleb ever found out he was the one who helped me.

Kaleb’s ass is so snug as I continue to draw my finger out and slowly shove it back in. My eyes are glued to the way his cock jerks, balls drawing up tight.

I pull my finger out and replace it with the end of the butt plug. It's much bigger than my finger.

I give him one last look. “Anything?” I ask.

He fixes me with a venomous glare, saying nothing. So I give the toy one hard shove and slide it into his arse. With the lube and the soft silicone shape, it slides right in, his ass opening up to the intrusion.

The way his body trembles, glowing with a sheen of sweat, has my pussy throbbing. I reach around and press a button, and immediately a soft, vibrating buzz echoes in the space. His nipples go tight, and he now... now he fights against the restraints.

It’s so beautiful to watch him unravel like this.

Neck straining, jaw grinding, eyes lidding. A drop of sweat slides between his clavicle, carving a line down his carved torso.

I watch him jerk against the cross, and his cock bobs heavily. Pressing my body against his, I reach between us, wrapping my hand around his cock. Each breath he takes sounds pained. Only exacerbated when I slide my palm over him, gripping him tightly.

“Does it hurt?” I whisper, searching his eyes. “Does it ache in the worst way?”

His nostrils flare, face twisting into a snarl.

“That’s what it felt like for me,” I continue, whispering the words onto his lips. “Ecstasy so strong that my body couldn’t cope. Each orgasm blending into one, never-ending cycle of agony.” I give him a soft smile, my hand finding a faster pace. “But you already know that, don’t you?”

The vibrations grow louder, and his mouth pops open. Those dark eyes slide to my lips, and for a second, I think he’s going to kiss me. I don’t give him the chance, circling my palm over his tip.

“Roxy,” he gasps. I fight the reaction at hearing him call me Roxy for the first time. It sends pulsing heat spiralling into my pussy. His added moans only deepen the ache. “Roxy, please.”

His whispered pleas make my body feel like molten lava. Instantly becoming an addict to it. He groans, body arching off the cross and into me, his aching cock pulsing and spilling hot seed over my grip. I use it to continue jerking him, his hips writhing between me and the toy that’s shoved deep in his ass.

“Goddamn, fuck!” he grits out louder this time.