“Fuck Alex,” she cries, and I’m tempted to keep going. I know what Nate said, but his order wasn’t for me; besides, I don’t give a fuck what he says.
The cool metal of her plug rubs against my cock, and I manage to pry my hands away. The second I let her go, she collapses onto Nate’s chest, panting and whimpering his name and then mine.
“Shhh, let Alex take care of you, my love.” Nate brushes some of her hair out of her face before giving me a nod, and I nearly come on the spot, knowing what’s about to happen.
I back up a little bit, wiping a hand over my mouth in disbelief. She’s in the perfect position now, her ass on full display.
Movement at my side makes me look over, and I spot a bottle of lube near my knee. Looking over, I find Vince sprawled in a chair, cock in hand, and I can’t blame him. I’d held off before, but if this wasn’t me, well, I probably wouldn’t be so well-behaved. No wonder they had me go last.
I give him a half-hearted salute and scoop up the lube, squeezing more than necessary on my cock, ensuring I get every inch.
The last thing I want is to hurt Kat. I want her to love this, which means I need to make sure this is about her and her comfort. We have all the time in the world to fuck in every way, but we need her to trust us with her.
I sink my teeth into my bottom lip, so on edge that every pass of my own hand leaves me shaky, nearly ready to blow, and I haven’t even pulled out the damn plug yet.
No better time than now.
I run my lubed-up hand down her ass, around the flared base of the plug, pulling slightly before I push it back in, and fuck me, if she doesn’t make the most beautiful sound.
I do it again, and again, slowly getting faster, pushing harder until she’s begging, her voice a raspy plea that I could get off on all by itself.
Next time.
Pushing it in one last time, I pull it all the way out, this time letting it fall away to who-the-fuck-cares-where as I line my cock up with her entrance.
“It’s going to feel tight. If it hurts, tell me, and I’ll stop, but make sure you breathe, baby.”
It takes every bit of my willpower to keep myself there until she nods, but with it is the most desperate ‘please’ I’ve ever heard.
“Anything you want, baby.”
I press in slowly, but between the lube and her ‘help’ from my brother, it doesn’t take nearly as long as I thought it would, and with a little more force, I manage to press the whole head of my cock in.
My vision nearly blacks out for a second as she grips me so fucking tight I have to breathe through the urge to empty my balls right now.
I could live in her ass, and after this I just might. It’s too bad I can’t get her pregnant like this, but I already have one; I can afford to give the others a chance to catch up.
I look at Nate to check on her and get another nod of approval, so I slowly start pushing in deeper. This isn’t mine and Nate’s first time with a woman between us like this, but it is hers. Most women we’d been with were well seasoned; they knew what they wanted, and we liked it like that.
Kat isn’t like anyone else we’d been with in the last fifteen years, at least.
She’s tight as fuck and not just for me if the way Nathan’s head falls back is anything to go off of.
I’m so close to being fully seated inside her when she whines, and I stop.
“Use your words,” Oliver says from the side of the bed, and I honestly had forgotten he was here.
“It’s too much,” she whimpers as she tightens around me further.
Nate and I both curse, but neither of us moves.
“Do you want them to stop?” Oliver asks, and thank fuck for this kid because I can’t seem to get my mouth to work with my head right now.
I force my eyes open and focus on Kat when she stays quiet too long. Her gaze is fixed on Oliver's, her pupils blown wide, sweat across her brow, her hair a mess as she gasps and pants.
A vision.
“No.”