Page 16 of Bad Men's Good Girl

She isn't reading from a guidebook. She’s gesturing toward the rough chisel marks on a torso, her face animated by a genuine, unforced wonder.

"Look at the tension in the shoulder," she says, voice carrying just enough to reach me. "He knew exactly what was inside that block before he even touched it. He wasn't creating them; he was letting them out."

The girl who stepped off the plane in a cloud of indecision is gone. This version of Baleigh walks with a different cadence, her shoulders back, her eyes sharp with observation. She doesn't look to me for the right answer anymore. She searches for her own.

A strange, quiet pride tightens my chest. It’s a dangerous sensation, something far more personal than the professional satisfaction of a successful mentor. I’ve spent twenty years watching students pass through these halls, but I’ve never seen a transformation this visceral. She is breaking out of her own stone, and I find I cannot look away.

The students drift toward the sun-drenched exit, their voices echoing through the gallery until the heavy silence of the Renaissance settles back over us. I should be checking my watch. I have a syllabus to refine and a dean to email.

Instead, I’m leaning against a pedestal, trapped in the orbit of Baleigh’s latest theory.

"The printing press didn't just democratize information, Max. It killed the mystery," she says, her eyes flashing witha playful defiance. "Suddenly, you didn't have to seek out the master to learn the truth. You just had to buy the book. We traded the soul of the lesson for the convenience of the page."

"And yet, without that convenience, you wouldn't be standing here debating it with me," I counter. "You’re arguing against the very mechanism that allowed your own education."

She laughs, a bright, unbridled sound that bounces off the vaulted ceiling. "I’m arguing for the human element. The master and the apprentice. The spark that happens when two people actually engage instead of just absorbing data."

She steps closer, her scent—something like citrus and warm paper—cutting through the stale museum air. For twenty minutes, we weave through centuries, jumping from Brunelleschi’s ego to the modern tragedy of the digital classroom. She doesn't just listen; she dissects my points and hands them back to me with a better perspective. It’s a rare, terrifying thrill. Most people agree with me out of habit or rank. Baleigh forces me to fight for my ground, and she does it with a smile that makes me want to lose the argument just to hear her explain why I’m wrong.

"You're a dangerous woman, Baleigh Butler," I murmur, the words slipping out despite my attempt to control myself.

"I'm just a woman who finally has something to say." She tilts her head, her gaze lingering on mine a second too long for professional comfort.

An hour later, I find myself in the Piazza della Signoria. I’m supposed to meet the program directors for coffee, but my eyes aren't scanning the crowd for the gray hair of my colleagues. They are searching for a flash of dark blonde, a specific flowy sundress, a certain kinetic energy.

I see her near the fountain, laughing at something Atticus is showing her on his camera. A sharp, cold needle of jealousy pricks at me, sudden and unwelcome. I’ve lived a disciplinedlife—measured, academic, predictable. But as I watch her, the truth settles in my gut with the weight of an anchor. This isn't mentorship. It isn't professional pride.

I’m falling for her, and even after forty years, I don’t know how to control the descent.

The logisticsfor the Orvieto trip are sprawled across the communal table in the staff lounge, a mess of train schedules and dietary restriction lists. I’m marking the map when the door swings open. Amos stumbles in, balancing three cardboard coffee carriers with the practiced grace of someone living in transit.

Baleigh is right at his heels, clutching a bag of pastries. She’s laughing—that deep, melodic sound that has become the background radiation of my days.

"I’m telling you, Amos, the GPS was right," she says, bumping her shoulder against his as they reach the table. "You just have a personal vendetta against technology."

"I have a vendetta against being led into a pedestrian-only alleyway by a robotic voice," Amos shoots back. He doesn't look up, but he doesn't have to; he reaches out blindly and plucks a croissant from the bag she’s holding, his fingers brushing hers for a beat longer than necessary.

The air between them is thick with it—the easy, unthinking shorthand of people who have spent their late nights whispering. She moves into his physical space like she’s stepping into a familiar room. He makes a joke about a "local shortcut" that ended in a vineyard, and she finishes the sentence before he can, both of them dissolving into a private mirage of humor I wasn't invited to share.

I feel a strange, hollow thump in my chest. It isn’t the sharp bite of envy I expected, but rather a sudden, cold clarity. I’vebeen viewing Baleigh as a singular revelation. I forgot she is a catalyst.

The door creaks again, and Atticus drifts in. He carries his Leica like an extra limb, his presence usually a quiet, ghostly thing. But the moment he spots Baleigh, his posture shifts. The weary, guarded lines around his eyes smooth out.

"I got those test shots back from the olive grove," Atticus says. He ignores the coffee, walking straight to Baleigh and turning the camera screen toward her.

He stands close—not with Amos’s boisterous energy, but with a focused, hungry stillness. As Baleigh leans in to see the photos, Atticus watches her face instead of the screen. His expression is terrifyingly readable. It’s the look of one who has spent his life documenting the world and just found the only subject he actually wants to keep.

I look from Amos’s casual arm draped over the back of her chair to Atticus’s intense, silent devotion. Then I look at my own hands, resting flat on the cold wood of the table. The realization isn't a spark; it's a landslide. We are three men of vastly different temperaments, all orbiting the same sun.

"Max?" Baleigh asks, her eyes turning toward me, bright and expectant. "You okay? You look like you're calculating the fall of Rome."

I force a smile, the muscles of my face feeling like dry parchment.

"Just the logistics, Baleigh," I lie. "Just the logistics."

The office remains bathed in a bruised purple light as the sun slips behind the hills of Bellosguardo. I don’t turn on the lamp. The rhythmic chime of the Duomo’s bells rolls through the open window, heavy and resonant, marking the hour with a finality that makes my heart skip. Usually, this is the time I find most productive—the quiet margin where the day’s chaos settles into data.

Tonight, the data doesn't add up.