“I have a wedding present for you,” she said with a smile.
“So, we really did just get married?” I asked. “Like, I obviously know that’s not a thing for us officially, but is this our wedding night and our future anniversary date? Because if so, I’d like to make note of it so we can celebrate.”
Kayden laughed and crawled up my body, kissing my cheek. “Do you want to call me your husband?”
“Yes,” I said without hesitation.
“Then go for it, babe,” he said. “You too, Olivia. I don’t need a piece of paper to give us permission to do that.”
“Boys, my hip is throbbing and I just got stabbed a trillion times,” Olivia said with a sigh.
Kayden raised an eyebrow at her overdramatization.
“If you don’t both call me your wife after what I just did, I will literally poke you with a thousand needles in your sleep,” she said, glaring at me.
I widened my eyes at Kayden. “Not sure about you, but that sounds kind of hot.” Liv slapped my shoulder, and I started laughing. “Okay, well then mark the date because next year I’m taking you somewhere tropical to celebrate our anniversary.”
“Great, we’re as married as we can be,” Olivia said. “Now, on to my wedding present.”
She smiled proudly and my dick twitched. I reached down and stroked Kayden.
“I want you to fuck me together,” she said.
Kayden’s dick leaked in the palm of my hand. It was obviously something we both wanted, but we’d already found a million different ways to bring each other pleasure without Olivia having to explore anal until she was ready.
I sat up and cupped her face, giving her a hard kiss. “I would love to get inside your ass, but we do not need to rush this. It might be better if you try anal without both of us inside you the first time.”
Olivia laughed. “First, I’ve waited long enough, I want it like this. Second, there is no way you are going in my ass first. Your dick is bigger, and it’s pierced.”
Kayden snorted. “Why does it feel like I won something while being insulted?” There was nothing insulting about the size of Kayden’s dick, he was still above average, and he knew it.
“If you want to do this, we’re going slow,” I said, kissing her again.
“Fun sucker.” Liv pouted.
Kayden grabbed lube from the nightstand and crawled over to us. “I agree with him.”
I smiled and kissed her pout. “Trust us. Lie down on your side.”
She lay down and Kayden crawled behind her and curled his chest against her back. He lubed up his fingers and gently pressed them to her ass. She’d been having fun with the various ass toys in my drawer for weeks, so the sensation wasn’t entirely new to her, and she moaned in pleasure as he gently thrust his fingers in and out of her. After several minutes of prepping her, he nodded to me and I lay down in front her of her and lined my dick up.
“Ready, sweetheart?”
She glared at me and grabbed my dick, pulling me to her entrance. She pushed herself on my dick and moaned. “I’m not fragile and I want you both to fuck me.”
I swiped her hair over her shoulder and kissed her neck as I gently moved my hips inside her. I could feel Kayden’s fingers in her ass, and she only felt tighter with him taking up space inside her. I slowed my hips ashe withdrew and squirted lube on his dick. He stroked himself until he was nice and slick.
“Olivia,” he said as he got into position behind her.
“Do not ask me again, Kayden,” she said looking over her shoulder at him. “I want to feel both of my husbands inside me and I don’t want to ask again.”
Kayden chuckled and locked eyes with me as he slowly pushed in. His eyes rolled backward, and he groaned, pausing part way. “Fucking hell, Olivia.”
I could only imagine how tight her ass must feel to him because her pussy clenched around me in a grip that made me barely able to move. I reached around her and grabbed Kayden’s hip as Olivia adjusted to both of us and he pushed himself in further. I slowly started moving my hips since it was clear that Kayden wouldn’t last long. Olivia moaned as I did, and Kayden let out a string of curses. “Fuck, Jace, I can feel your dick moving against mine. It feels like you’re fucking me too,” he said.
“I want to feel you move too, Kayden,” Olivia said, looking back at him.
“Honestly, I’m not sure I can do that,” he croaked.
