Page 39 of Sweet Lies


Font Size:

Amanda pressed the advantage, her voice turning sharp and lethal. "It is over. There is no putting Olivia back in the dark now. There is no sweet, manipulative apology that will make her un-see what just happened on those sheets. There is no version of this where she comes back home tonight and pretends to be your trusting little wife again."

"You don't know Olivia," James argued stubbornly.

"I know enough," Amanda sneered. "I know she looked broken, but she did not look stupid. You have been underestimating your wife for years, James, just because it made lying to her easier. Well, she isn't blind anymore."

The truth stung, and James flinched. "You made this worse," he accused, his voice rising again. "You taunted her! You pushed her!"

"I made it worse?" Amanda screamed, jabbing a finger into his chest, her composure breaking as the sheer unfairness of his accusation hit her. "You made it worse by bringing me into this house, into this bed, and into your marriage! You assured me she would not be coming back to the house tonight. That is why I agreed to come here! Do you think I would be stupid enough to expose myself to this kind of risk if you hadn't sworn we were safe?"

"You wanted this too!" James defended himself.

"Yes, I did!" Amanda yelled right back in his face, her voice cracking with raw, unvarnished pain. "But I did not agree to be discarded like trash the second she found out! We have plans, James! And right now, you are scared, and you are acting dumb."

"I never said I was discarding you."

"You tried to call our relationship a mistake with me standing right there!"

"I was buying time!" James shot back desperately.

"You were buying yourself a way out!" Amanda roared.

The silence that followed was heavy and hostile. Amanda breathed heavily, feeling a toxic mix of rage, jealousy, and cold, calculating fear. She did not want to lose James. She loved the power, the money, and the intoxicating thrill of being his chosen equal. But even more than that, she absolutelyrefused to be the only one left paying the price for his reckless choices.

If Olivia had proof of the financial fraud, James could go down. And if James went down, Amanda knew she could easily be dragged right into the mud with him. She refused to become the disposable mistress in a public scandal. She was not going to lose her high-paying corporate job. She was not going to be named in messy legal documents, shredded in workplace gossip, or listed as the homewrecker in a high-profile divorce proceeding while James offered her up as a meaningless lapse in judgment to save his own skin.

She forced her racing heart to slow down. She locked her emotions behind a wall of pure survival instinct and shifted gears.

"If you go running after Olivia right now," Amanda said, her voice dropping into a terrifyingly calm, strategic register, "you will look desperate. You will look guilty. You will give her all the power."

James swallowed hard, his panic ebbing as her logic cut through the noise. "I have to stop her before she talks."

"No," Amanda corrected sharply. "Trying to stop her directly will only make you look worse. You don't need to stop her. You need to control the story."

James stared at her.

"You already started doing it," Amanda reminded him. "You went to her friends. You planted the seeds. Now you need to be smarter. You need a plan. You need to know exactly what proof she has, who she has told, and what she intends to do next."

Amanda watched him process the shift. She was angry, yes, but she was calculating. James was drowning in panic; Amanda was building a lifeboat.

"There is only one way for us to get out of this unscathed," Amanda told him, her dark eyes locking onto his.

"What do you mean?" James asked, his voice rough.

Amanda stepped closer, her mind moving with rapid, ruthless precision. "Olivia is highly emotional. She is humiliated. And right now, she is staying under the roof of a man who has obvious feelings for her. We can use that."

James went perfectly still, the shape of what she was suggesting slowly dawning on him.

"We don't need Olivia to forgive you right away," Amanda explained, her voice smooth and venomous. "We just need people to doubt her. We need people to wonder if Leo influenced her into making up these accusations. We need her friends and the board to question whether Olivia is actually reacting to a betrayal, or if she is just using your financial mistakes as a convenient excuse to run off with another man."

James did not argue. He did not defend his wife's honor. He just listened.

"You cannot chase her like a guilty husband begging for forgiveness," Amanda instructed. "You have to look like the reasonable one. The worried one. The abandoned one. You are the man desperately trying to save his marriage while his unstable wife is being pulled away by someone else."

Amanda touched her burning cheek, then looked at the man who had almost made the mistake of choosing panic over survival.

"You’re not going after her," she said. "You’re going to make everyone wonder why she ran to him."

James stared at her as the meaning settled over his face.