“Like that,” Cubby purrs, pushing back and wiggling for me. “I like how it feels when you explore me.”
I press my palms to his cheeks. The hair is soft there, downy, and I’m surprised by how much I like the feel of it against my fingers. My eyes are fixated on his bare flesh, even more tempting than when I imagined it while jerking off, but nothing prepares me for his hole when I pull his cheeks apart.
There’s a thin line of hair down his crack, then a puckered rim, twitching for me.
“Oh fuck,” I groan. I want to feel him. Smell him. Taste him.
My world destabilizes. I’m meeting this raw, primal need—and how did I not know I wanted this?
“Lube,” Cubby gasps. His face is buried in a throw pillow, and I see that he’s playing with his cock while he offers his ass to me. “Lube, please.”
I reach over to the side table, where I stashed a little bottle earlier, and squirt some in my hand, which is shaking. I’m about to feel the inside of another man’s body, and the reality of that makes my breath hitch.
Fuck. I want to know what Cubby feels like inside.
“Chase,” he begs. “Please. I need you to fuck me with your hand.”
I growl at him and kick my boxers off, freeing my hard dick. “One finger first?”
Cubby nods quickly, his face still in the pillow. “Work my rim until I loosen up.”
I take his ass with one hand, pulling him open. I’m between his legs, one foot on the ground, our bodies sprawling off the couch. Cubby’s scent is rich in the air, manly in a way I can’t describe, and I watch his rim, a pink pucker with a swirl of dark hair.
I reach out my lubed-up fingers and rub a slow circle. Cubby’s entrance twitches, squeezing as a quiver works its way through his body. “Fuck yeah.”
My cock swells, pleasure burning from my root. “You feel good.”
I keep working him, and I’m so turned on, I swear I can feel the tight suction as though it were seizing my dick and not just my fingertip. Cubby starts thrashing and pushing his hips back, moaning my name into the pillow.
“In me,” he pleads. “I’m ready.”
My heart pounding like a jackhammer, I push one finger inside him. Cubby moans my name as he opens for me. His seizing entrance pulls me into something warm and soft and good, and I realize I’m groaning his name, like he’s moaning mine.
With a shuddered breath, I let go of the cheek I’m groping and reach forward to tug his shoulder. “Want to see you,” I rasp.
Cubby’s hole clenches as he turns. Slowly, he spins on my finger, getting to his back. His face is flushed, his hair sweaty, and there’s heat in his wide eyes.
“Fuck, you’re handsome,” I tell him.
“And you’re so good-looking, it’s probably a sin.” Cubby works his hips, taking me deeper. “Right there,” he breathes. “Curl your finger. You feel that?”
I do what he says, stroking. I find something harder that pulses back, and when it does, Cubby’s cock twitches, leaking milky precum on his belly.
“Oh fuck,” I grunt, then stroke him there again, earning an even bigger reaction.
I push another finger in, and Cubby grinds his hips down, taking me harder against his spot. He’s sweaty and demanding what he wants. He grabs my wrist and pumps his hips, holding my eye the whole time.
Fuck, his confidence is hot. The room smells like us, musky, and precum is dripping down my crown. I’ve got three fingers in his ass now, pumping harder and harder, and I fucking love every second of it.
Cubby tightens his grip on my wrist, stopping me. His hole clenches around my fingers, and he lets out a moan. “Going to come,” he gasps, “if you keep going.”
I curl my fingers, stroking the spot he showed me, which pulses hard and hot. “Fuck yeah. I want to make you come.”
I crawl on top of Cubby, my fingers buried in his hole. I get a strong urge to rub our cocks together and somehow find a way to get in place, thrusting my whole body against his like last time we hooked up.
“Chase! Chase! Oh fuck! Oh fuck!”
Cubby convulses underneath me, my hand between our legs. I work my fingers in and out of his slick hole, and our shafts rub together. We both get wild, humping and cursing and thrusting, and when I feel Cubby’s rim grip me hard, I explode.
