Page 16 of The Sin Eater


Font Size:

"You can ask. I might not answer."

"What happened when you were young? The thing that made you like this—controlled and careful and afraid of letting anyone close?"

I should've deflected. Should've shut down the question like I did with everyone who tried to get too personal.

Instead I heard myself say: "My stepfather hurt my younger sister. I found out when I was thirteen. Put him in the hospital. My family covered it up and sent me away to military school where I learned that control was the only thing that kept me from becoming a monster like him."

Julian was quiet. Then: "You're not a monster. You protected someone who couldn't protect themselves. That's not monstrous. That's brave."

"I nearly killed him. Would have if my mother hadn't pulled me off."

"He deserved it."

The certainty in Julian's voice startled me.

"You don't know the details—"

"I know enough. I know what it's like to fight back against someone who hurts you. To be punished for defending yourself. To spend years thinking you were wrong for protecting yourself when everyone around you said you should've just accepted it." Julian leaned forward. "You weren't wrong, Elio. You were thirteen and protecting your sister. That's not something to be ashamed of."

Something cracked in my chest. Something I'd kept carefully controlled for many years.

"How did you get so good at seeing through people?" My voice came out rougher than intended.

"I spent five years watching. Learning. Trying to understand the people around me so I could survive them." Julian's expression softened. "You're not as hard to read as you think. At least not to someone who's been looking."

"And you've been looking?"

"Yes."

The admission hung between us. Honest. Direct. Dangerous.

I should've left. Should've put distance between us before this conversation went places it couldn't go.

Instead I stayed in my chair and let Julian's eyes hold mine.

"Why?" I asked.

"Because you're the first person who's ever looked at me and seen someone dangerous instead of someone fragile. Because you treat me like I'm capable of real damage instead of something that needs protecting." He paused. "Because when you're in the room, I feel safer than I've felt in years. And I don't understand why."

I understood why. I understood exactly why.

Because Julian recognized something in me that matched something in himself. Because we'd both learned control through pain. Because we both knew what it was like to be punished for defending ourselves.

Because attraction didn't care about age gaps or power dynamics or the hundred reasons this was a terrible idea.

"Julian—"

"I know." He cut me off gently. "I know all the reasons this is complicated. I know I'm too young. I know I'm under your protection. I know getting involved would be a disaster." He stood and started clearing the dishes. "But I wanted you to know anyway. That I see you. That I notice. That whatever this is—" he gestured between us "—it's not just in my head."

He handed me the tray. Our fingers brushed. Just for a second. Just enough for electricity to arc between us.

Julian pulled back first. Stepped away. Put deliberate distance between us.

"Thank you for dinner," he said. "And for telling me about your sister. I know that wasn't easy."

I stood. Took the tray. Walked to the door on autopilot.

Paused with my hand on the handle.