Page 145 of It Could Only Be You


Font Size:

And maybe that’s what I need to learn too.

Not how to forget or how to excuse.

But how to stop letting what was taken dictate what comes next.

Sarah shifts just enough to look at me. “She came by today.”

My chest tightens, but not in the way I expect. “Sierra?”

She nods. “She apologized,” she says.

I wait.

“She cried,” Sarah adds. “But she kept herself contained. Like she didn’t want anyone to mistake it for an excuse. It’s like she was trying to hold herself together because she doesn't feel she deserves comfort.”

My chest tightens.

“She didn’t ask me for anything,” Sarah continues. “And she didn’t try to explain herself or soften it. She just said she knew her choice changed things she had no right to.”

I hold her gaze. “And?”

“I forgave her,” I say. “Not because it doesn’t matter. And not because it fixes anything. I did it because I don’t want this to keep owning me.”

The words settle between us. I know this is the part where anger is supposed to show up, but it doesn’t.

Instead, something steadier takes its place. Respect. Understanding. The quiet relief of knowing Sarah didn’t forgive out of weakness, but out of self-preservation.

“Thank you for telling me,” I say honestly.

“I didn’t want you to feel blindsided,” she replies. “Or think I did it for her.”

“I know you didn’t.”

She watches me closely. “Does it bother you?”

“No,” I answer, and realize it’s true. “It actually helps. Knowing she owned it. Knowing you chose peace.”

Her eyes shine, but she doesn’t cry. “I don’t want this to define us,” she says quietly.

I lift her chin gently. “It won’t. Not when I get to choose what comes next.”

She exhales, something like relief slipping free.

I pull her closer again, pressing my forehead to hers. “I’m not ready to talk to Sierra yet. I will be. Just… not today.”

“I understand,” she says without hesitation.

I close my eyes.

This is what choosing looks like. No fireworks or big declarations.

Just staying honest, and refusing to disappear.

Later, when the house is quiet and the lights are low, when her body fits against mine like something that’s always known where it belongs, the intimacy shifts again. Slower this time. Deliberate. Affirming.

I don’t remember deciding to stand. I just do, like my body is finally done sitting inside itself. Sarah rises with me, close, her hands sliding up my arms, her eyes never leaving mine.

“What do you need?” she asks, soft.